My first season on the canal I drove mules for a freight boat, and that captain was a fiendish drunk named, truthfully, Fowler. He made me sleep outside with the mules, even in the springtime chill. At the end of the season, he deprived me of all my wages. I returned to my family’s farm sick, ghost-pale, with bones protruding, nothing in my pockets. My father lashed me, almost happily, I thought, pleased that out in the world I’d only made less of my matter, my rottenness confirmed. Even ill and laid up, I knew I’d run away to canal work as soon as the frost was over. At the farm, the sky was ashen and the land brown. There was never enough food, and my older sisters conspired to keep away from me what little there was. My mother, waxen and silent, nursed my baby brother, the only one of us who was fat and happy still, the only one I loved.
When my thirteenth birthday passed and green patches erupted on tree branches, I dove into the back of a pig cart, pushed up against their flesh and mewling snouts. We made it to Albany after an hour’s ride. At the docks it was no different. Boys clamoring over each other in big clusters, boasting and cursing, snatching things away from the youngest ones of nine or ten, and looking for a boat to work on. The spring air vibrated with all the shouts, brays, and heaves. Along the canal, the long boats moved with the ghostly smoothness of a fish, just slipping past one another. Each was attached by a rope to a pair of mules who plodded the towpaths on either side of the canal and pulled the boats along the water. With every pair of mules, riding or walking beside them, there was another boy. I recognized some from the year before, but they said nothing to me. I worried I had a stink about me from not getting paid. Such news spread. No one wanted to be stained by the association, though I knew of many cases aside from my own. The boys always talked tough to each other when it happened, mumbling that the captain should watch his back, that a band of friends at the next port wouldn’t be pleased to see him. But those friends never seemed to appear.
Wanting to be on my own, I climbed up into the high branches of a beech tree. The stench of the shit of a hundred mules and horses fused with the putrid odor of the canal. I loved that smell, rotten and alive at the same time. I felt if I inhaled deeply enough, some grass might sprout from my nose. There was much more of the world I hoped to see. It was my secret ambition to own and operate my own packet boat someday and carry passengers from all over the country up and down the canal. In my reverie, I imagined Fowler in a desperate state, years in the future, trying to board my boat in a storm and not recognizing me. He turns away in shame when he hears the cost of my well-appointed accommodations. In one fantasy, I allow him to spend the night anyway, offering him food and drink with great magnanimity. In another, I push him overboard. In yet another it is not Fowler at all, but my father.
A thick-armed man with a robust horseshoe mustache spotted me up in the tree. He pointed his finger right at my chest and flapped the rest so that I might come to him. He told me he was Captain Beekman and asked me my name. He said it would be good to have a boy on board who could climb high. Otherwise, he wanted only to know that I was God-fearing before I set a hand on his mules. I shrugged and said I supposed I was. I had gone once with my sisters to Sunday school, but the teacher had talked mostly about the importance of keeping a clean face and bottom. We never returned.
Beekman and his wife ran a packet boat for pleasure-seeking canal riders, though it was nothing like what I imagined mine might be someday. It was cramped and dusty, with flies buzzing and a musty smell that nagged at you.
“Show some respect when I introduce you to my wife.” Beekman took me to where she was standing beside their mules.
I stretched my hand to her. She nodded but didn’t offer her own back. She was the tallest woman I’d ever seen, taller still because of her reddish blond hair, which was piled haphazardly atop her head. She had tiny, close-together dark eyes, blotchy pink skin, and flared nostrils like she’d just smelled something rancid. I started calling her Piggy in my head then, and now I can’t remember her real name or if I ever even knew it.
“This is Samson,” Piggy said of the mule with a white forelock so long and full I felt sure he couldn’t see a thing except what was right at his feet. The other mule was named Delilah, of course, but was, Piggy assured me, male.
She gathered in her arms a minuscule and sickly lapdog by the name of The Baron and led me on a tour through the packet boat. The Baron had an underbite of pointy little teeth and his black, unfocused eyes seemed to be peering already and with some longing into the afterlife. Piggy had carefully tied up The Baron’s fur, long and stringy, with tiny bows of butter-yellow ribbon all over his body. The Baron couldn’t use his hind legs, and Beekman had rigged for his wife’s beloved a small wooden board with wheels, tied to the Baron’s lower half, that allowed him some mobility. It was clear, though, that Piggy preferred to carry the old dog.
“If there’s bunks free, you’ll sleep in the cabin with the passengers. But if we’re full up, you’ll sleep there,” Piggy said, nodding to a small area across from the cook stove. It was a makeshift stable stall that jutted out onto the stern, built from the haphazard nailing together of many different kinds and sizes of wooden planks. Some straw and a tattered blanket lay on the floor. “You’ll be alongside the mules when the weather’s bad.”
Next, we walked through the main room, with its rough wooden table and threadbare seats and gauzy, yellowed curtains hanging here and there. Folded up along the walls were the bunks. Piggy said we would take them down each evening and we could expect some fifty travelers a night. She and Beekman slept behind one of the heavier curtains. At the foot of their cot was a chest on top of which sat a small domed canopy of red velvet that held, ensconced within it, plush cushions of the same material, embroidered with white roses: The Baron’s bed. Piggy gently slid the dog’s squirming body onto it as she scolded me preemptively, saying that she knew the whereabouts of every bip and bauble on board, and if I had any inkling to steal, she’d know before I’d even touched a thing. While she was talking, I reached out to pet The Baron. My fingers had just grazed his oily fur when Piggy slapped my hand away.
“No! You’re forbidden from stroking The Baron until I know better your . . . proclivities.”
I considered fleeing then. Grown men and ladies came in many bodies but mostly, it seemed, shared an identical foul spirit. Or perhaps there was just something about me then, as tempting to kick as a rotted pumpkin. I did not leave. I stood and said nothing and stared up at her and into her nostrils. I’d heard of others whose captains had taken an interest in them, set them up at a home for boys in Syracuse or Rochester for the winter and even bought them workbooks for lessons or some boots. Usually, they said, this was achieved not only by hard work and obedience, but by appealing to the sensitive dispositions of the captains’ wives, who got especially wet-eyed over orphans, which I was, unfortunately, not. I feared the narrow chamber of Piggy’s heart was fully occupied already by The Baron’s little, quaking body. But I hoped that if I could learn to be useful I might be tolerated and perhaps even something more.
————
Each day, I walked the mules from morning until supper, with a few hours rest in between. We marched past wide pastures, wet emerald dotted with puffs of sheep, or skirted the edge of dark old woods, whose tall trees bent toward the canal like a beckoning hand. It was tiring, and all along my feet blisters broke out, pale and round as the moon. Soon they turned red and raw, each pace along the towpath like stepping on embers, my face puckered in pain. I was lucky that Samson and Delilah proved themselves to be agreeable animals, Delilah consenting to my riding on his back when the agony of my feet was too much to bear. As the blisters turned to callouses, I came to know the mules’ rhythms and wants, and I made sure to brush them extra and give them nice long breaks from the harness so their skin wouldn’t chafe.
The passengers on the packet boat congregated on the long roof, where I could observe them unnoticed from my position on the towpath. On the canal I encountered hitherto unimaginable types of people. There was a troupe of musicians and performers who were meeting up with the circus in Rochester. For practice, the acrobats tumbled the length of the roof, stopping just short of its edge. There was an acne-ridden Bible salesman whom I never saw sell a Bible, only tiny bottles of sulfur water from Saratoga Springs. He spoke sometimes with the Valentine sisters, Estelle and Rosemary, two spinsters who balanced delicate parasols over their shoulders, covered their faces in lace veils, and claimed to have a direct channel to the dead.
In the day, we were under Piggy’s dominion. She was always shouting at someone, often me, or else muttering about the damage these circus freaks were doing to her boat. Piggy’s food, though, was better than I expected it to be, fish stews and cod cakes and date puddings, and she wasn’t too stingy with portions. I once smelled her frying up bacon, but my hopes were dashed when I saw it was just for herself and The Baron. Piggy held the dog on her lap as she slipped small pieces of glistening hot fat over the hump of his overbite, and I stared in disgust and envy.
At night, I was regularly awoken by all manner of human noises in the bunks. The area was divided between men and women by a floral curtain, thin and stained. If a womanly sound sailed over to our side, a loud and lusty vulgarity would often be shouted back, and, if we were lucky, a response again from the women’s side. There were fits of sputum-thick coughing and belches that exploded from the deepest, swampiest part of the belly. I was roused so many times by the sound and stench of various farts that I began to assemble a taxonomy of them in my mind: airy ones, fat ones, ones that went off like firecrackers. When I couldn’t sleep, I even sometimes thought fondly of my family, the familiar sounds of their particular bodies, my baby brother’s breathing. In these very late hours I listened to men vomit, weep, or whisper strange prayers and confessions that I strained to hear but could never quite understand.
But before the passengers went to sleep for the night, the roof turned into a place of debauched revelry, and I was often allowed to join. Beekman was at the center of this, after Piggy had turned in, the powerful thunder of her snores filling the cabin below. Nothing could wake her. He had demanded a commitment to temperance from me at the start of our journey, but Beekman was now slipping me sips of whiskey from his silver pocket flask. He also let me play cards with a little bit of his money, though I lost every time and wondered if the acrobats were cheats. When he didn’t want to gamble anymore, Beekman played his accordion with the musicians. Once, everyone on the boat turned to see Beekman writhing in his chair, his fists hurling themselves into the keys. His head rolled all the way back so that it rattled against his spine and his jaw crashed open like a cupboard door on a broken hinge. It seemed the pained moans of the instrument were coming from the wide darkness of his open mouth. Then, as if the spirit possessing him had grown suddenly bored, all movement left his body and he collapsed across the accordion. The bellows deflated under his weight, releasing a long dissonant bleat like the last gasp of an infected lung.
“Fits,” a lion tamer from the card game leaned over and whispered in my ear.
As Beekman roused himself and carried on playing and drinking, I imagined The Baron below in his opulent bed, turning his roving, black eyes to the ceiling in judgment.
The chatter on the roof often circled back to the celebrities that were suspected to be riding the canal at the same time as us. The Valentine sisters knew of them all. There was word, they said, of an outlaw who’d killed the Oneida sheriff and was skulking through the woods along the towpaths, chains still on his legs; the Preacher Garfield, who held revivals of a thousand worshippers in the woods, was touring the length of the canal; and the Louisville Leaper was performing stunts all summer.
Everyone went to the Leaper’s performance at the falls near Herkimer. The peak was foggy, but the Leaper’s compact body was visible, a little gray smudge on a small platform, flanked by the mad flapping of two American flags. With only a short wave at us below, the Leaper stepped easily off the platform. He shot through the mist, feet first, arms outstretched face turned upward. His expression was unperturbed, peaceful even, as though he should be ascending to heaven. He was fully dressed in brown leather shoes, a straw hat, and a bright red sash that trembled behind him like a comet’s tail. After he crashed into the water, I was certain he was dead. But a moment later, his hand emerged and gripped a rock, which he pulled his body onto. He sputtered and shook and bowed deep for the gasping crowd. There was suddenly slick sweat on the back of my neck and a feeling like all the people were closing in around me. I burst through the heavy skirts of the women and ran until I found a tree, leaned one hand on it, and retched, my head dizzy with images from the lock last year.
We had been stalled. I had been on the towpath with Fowler’s mules, the boat stuck before the closed wooden gates of the lock with a line of other boats behind us. Fowler shouted at me to leave the mules and run up to the top and find out about the holdup. A crowd of us up there, boys and boatmen, tried to see what was happening, the lock slowly filling back up with water. In the garden along the lock’s edge, swirls of bright yellow and white daffodils shivered, illuminated like little lanterns by the afternoon sun. As the water continued to rise, so did a bulging shape, pushed up against the far wall by the force of the water. I understood it was a body before I could say so in my own mind, and I kept staring at the daffodils to pretend it wasn’t. I followed a capricious bee as it flitted from flower to flower and then eventually flew out over the canal, and that’s when I looked. The man’s body was bloated and the skin taut and flimsy at once, a white so translucent it was nearly purple. The body flipped jerkily, so that the side of the face that still appeared like a man’s was submerged, and the side that had been in the water for much longer became visible. The whole world seemed, in a second, to turn counterfeit. The face transformed into a crude cartoon, some horrible puppet. The daffodils had been made unreal too, garish and shrieking and gawking, so bright and blind. Why hadn’t anyone told me not to look? I almost said the words aloud.
When I returned to the boat, Fowler laughed at me, and I thought maybe he’d known all along what the holdup was. And that night, long after the body was removed and we’d sailed through the lock, Fowler and the other men debated whether it had been a fight over a gambling debt or a drunken accident or premeditated murder. After that, every time we came to a lock, I performed some small charm, crossing my fingers and toes or stroking the mules a set number of times.
————
It was the start of summer when we caught up with Preacher Garfield’s boat. As with the Leaper, the preacher’s fame preceded him, and nearly everyone on board went to his revival that night. It was supposed to be held in a schoolhouse, but the size of the crowd wouldn’t allow it, and we congregated by a makeshift wooden pulpit in a clearing in the woods. Two bonfires marked the edges of the clearing and cast a waxy incandescence on the faces of the gathered crowd. Everything beyond what the fires illuminated was obliterated, a solid, depthless plane of black.
Garfield, tall and thin, braced himself on the balustrade of the pulpit, as though his body was already inhabited by and pulsing with the Holy Spirit. He was bald up to the crown of his head, and from there the hair was brushed back and cascaded down below his ears. The ridge of his brow was straight and severe, a promontory over the pale blue pools of his eyes, with the tiniest pinpricks for pupils in the center. I had never seen a stare like that before.
He frightened me at first. When he spoke it was with the vehemence of anger and punishment, a tone I’d heard so many times, but what he spoke of, what I can remember, what I could understand, was mercy and love.
“We live in the dominion of God,” he said. “But within each man is the kingdom of his own soul. He may possess a soul sullied by perversions, a soul gnarled by deprivation, a soul worn thin from the cruelty of others.” He paused as the words vibrated through the crowd and up into the air.
“But there is no soul that He cannot cleanse, cannot unravel, cannot mend.” He thumped his hands in a steady, slow rhythm on the balustrade.
“Salvation is here, waiting for each and every man who decides to step into His light. The capability lies in us all.”
I felt the air on my skin more acutely as his voice grew louder. My eyes moved between the hard black of his pupils and the ever-faster movement of his hands.
“Volunteer yourself, I beseech you. Once you begin again in virtue, there is little that can stop you from prospering, as long as you are brave enough to stretch your hand, open your palm, and grasp what might be yours.”
The crowd cried out in recognition. I felt like the cry came from my own mouth, even though I couldn’t bring myself to make a sound. An invisible hand had settled its warmth in the center of my chest. It was as if he was saying directly to me what I’d always hoped could be true, but not quite known: that I might choose.
But suddenly the preacher’s expression changed, his face transformed into something harsh. He shot the beam of his stare slowly across the audience and pointed a quivering finger at the crowd.
“The Spirit of the Lord has made it known to me that there is a great and particular wickedness here, and that it is my solemn duty to speak on the sin pervading this town, this crowd, this night.” He braced himself on the balustrade again, his voice turning to thunder. “In whom does this evil reside?”
The peace from a moment before was broken. And I was frightened but spellbound as all around me, people began to fling themselves onto the ground, quaking and praying, begging for mercy. I stood up on my toes in search of a familiar face. At the front of the crowd, Piggy and Beekman both prostrated themselves before the base of the pulpit. The Preacher Garfield descended now and prayed with each of the sinners, holding their skulls in his hands and casting out their various sins, so they lay panting and stunned in the dirt. He did the same to Beekman. But after Garfield released him from his grip, Beekman was suddenly flailing even more strangely, his limbs popping into the air, his tongue lolling from his mouth. When it happened to him before on the boat he had quickly returned to his senses, but this fit lasted longer. Garfield made a quick gesture to his left and moved on. I pushed to the front to see if Beekman was all right.
An old man with white hair rushed over and gripped Beekman’s hands while his body continued to shake. When I got closer, I realized he wasn’t elderly at all, but was around my age, a few years older. His hair was a blond so pale as to be confused for white, and it flopped over his forehead just like Samson the mule’s forelock. He lifted his head and his eyes were an even paler, icier blue than Garfield’s, framed by long, white lashes, and turned down at the edges, so that he looked sad and wise.
Beekman went still, and the boy with the white-blond hair put his hands under Beekman’s armpits and pulled him away from the crowd. I rushed to them. Beekman opened his eyes for a moment and shut them again, muttering something, and I knew he was fine enough, just drunk. I grabbed his legs, and the boy and I shuffled him off. Before we entered the darkness of the forest, Piggy, who was rocking and praying with her hands clasped in front of her face, cracked one eye open and gave me a nod of thanks, the first and last approval I would ever receive from her.
We struggled to carry Beekman, swinging like a hammock between us, through the woods and to a trail that led back to the canal. We laid him out on the ground, and I thought the boy would leave me here. But instead of turning away, he stuck his hand out to me over Beekman’s body.
“I’m Isaac,” he said. We shook hands as Beekman let out a loud belch below us.
Together, we got him to his feet and each slung one of his arms over our shoulders, the smell of his breath sticky in our noses as we stumbled toward the water.
We shoved Beekman onto his cot, The Baron yelping at us half-heartedly from beneath his canopy. Isaac stroked the little dog and hushed him, so that he curled up on his cushion and seemed almost sweet. We climbed to the roof of the boat, empty except for us.
I wanted to express my gratitude to Isaac, but unsure of what to say, I produced from my pocket Beekman’s silver flask, which I’d snatched as we’d carried him.
Isaac shook his head, not harshly, though, and lay down to look up at the sky. I twirled the cap to the flask open and closed, over and over, but didn’t take a swig.
Isaac asked, “You drive his mules?”
“That’s right,” I said.
“First time?”
“First time for this boat, second season on the canal.”
“How’s he treat you?”
“All right. Fine.” Then I asked, “Is he your dad? Garfield, I mean.”
Isaac turned on his side to face me, perplexed. “I work for him.”
It was his fourth season on the canal. He had worked for a year as a mule-driver for a captain who sounded even worse than Fowler. Then he’d driven mules for Garfield, who had taken a liking to him and made him a boatman the following year. And now, Garfield treated him as an apprentice, educating him to be a preacher himself.
“I’ll be a vessel,” he said, “to carry people to right moral action and the glory of God.”
He had a soft voice, but it was the kind that made you more certain of the value of his words. Suddenly, I was talking quite freely to Isaac about my own plans, my dream to possess a packet boat, which I had told absolutely no one before.
He nodded, as though it was a sensible desire and this future was something I would surely acquire. He asked me how many feet it would be, how many passengers it would hold. The boat’s contours and edges took shape in my mind as the sun’s first rays brightened the sky.
————
We started to keep apace with Garfield’s boat, and Isaac and I found our way to each other most days. Delilah developed a sore under his harness, and Isaac rubbed some kind of orange paste on him that cleared it in a day or two. He told me I should confess my theft of the pocket flask to Beekman. I said I’d consider it. After he left, I looked at my reflection, just visible in the murk of the canal water. I held a bit of Samson’s white mane up to my own head, wondering if the color might suit me. But the cloudiness of the reflection obscured my freckles, my brown hair, and my pink, sunburned cheeks, turning my face into an unrecognizable smear.
I knew it would be a mistake to tell Beekman the truth, but I did return the flask when he wasn’t looking. I no longer spent time on the roof at night. Through Isaac’s counsel, I also no longer drank whiskey, played cards, or cursed. If there was a revival, I went with Isaac, watching him watch Garfield from the crowd. And if there wasn’t one, Isaac and I would walk through the woods together. Isaac brought me to a lake near Medina one night and we floated naked on our backs, weightless in the cool, black water. At the end of the canal season, I imagined we might take a trip together to Niagara Falls, marvel at their immensity, get bathed in their spray, dare each other to climb closer and closer to the edge. I entertained myself with this vision of Niagara Falls and others during the long and tiring working hours. Perhaps when the season was over, Isaac and I would stick together. I would not return to the farm, but instead we would find a shared lodging. Preachers like Garfield were always opening their homes to what they called “itinerant boys,” or at least knew of the kind of places where such boys could go. And the next year, perhaps Garfield would tour New York again, and perhaps he would be in need of someone like me to pull his mules.
One night, a little ways past Rochester, Isaac and I returned from a late-night walk to see that no one was on the roof of Beekman’s boat. We peeked in the cabin and saw a ring of people grasping hands around the dining table, a burning white candle in the middle. The Valentine sisters were holding a séance. They had removed their lace veils and were more beautiful than I imagined. Rosemary had a scar that traveled from her Cupid’s bow to the edge of her left temple, and Estelle had a scar from her left temple that cut diagonally across her forehead and into her hairline. It was as though the sisters had been struck by the same lightning bolt.
The Valentine sisters began by calling out a letter or an image, and someone in the circle scrambled to claim it as their own—A is for my Abigail, God rest her soul! The sisters’ serene faces contorted, and their bodies spasmed as voices, throaty and pained and not their own, sprang from their lips, spitting forth messages from the other side: assurances, regrets, forgiveness. Their rapt and anguished audience pleaded always for one more word, like someone chasing after a breeze-blown hat. But the spirits departed quickly. Were the Valentine sisters communing with the dead? I thought so. Back then I believed more readily that a yearning for something was enough to make it true. Either way, I was mesmerized.
I almost wanted to applaud, but I looked nervously at Isaac. He was generally disapproving of the recreation on the packet boat, and I wanted to match my reaction to his. But he was just as enthralled as the rest of us. As the night wore on, I noticed several times that his downturned eyes were leaking tears that he wiped away discreetly with the cuff of his shirt. Isaac never spoke of his family, though I complained freely to him about mine. That night I came to suspect that Isaac was himself an orphan. Perhaps he was not simply transfixed by the sisters’ abilities, but hoping that the next spirit to contact them might be his own mother or father. I did not ask, but the suspicion resolved itself into certainty in my mind, the way suspicions sometimes do. While I had known a great many hardships in my short life, he had experienced pain that I couldn’t yet comprehend, which made me admire him all the more.
————
Soon after the séance, the rain began to fall for days. The towpaths grew thick with mud, and the mules and I were bone-tired and chattering with cold. My mood turned sour. Piggy berated me and yanked my ears for allowing the mules to get sores, though such was the result of driving them so hard through the rain. Even Isaac’s remedy could not fully heal them.
I went in search of him after I finished driving the mules for the day and found him soaked but seemingly unaware, pacing the towpath by Garfield’s boat. He listened to my grievances with his usual sympathy, becoming angry enough on my and the mules’ behalf that he described Piggy with a few profane words. This sounded so unusual coming from Isaac’s mouth that we both began to laugh. I asked what he was doing out here in the rain, and he explained to me that Garfield had requested that he give the opening sermon at the next revival in Buffalo, which we were to reach by the end of the week, and he was pondering what to say. He had never given a sermon himself before and knew nothing of what subject he’d discuss. The crowd would surely be immense. Not wanting to take up any more of his time, I wished him luck and returned to the mildewy innards of the packet boat.
To my misfortune, these rainy days were among the busiest of the canal season, and Beekman took to selling my bunk at night, unable to hide his glee at the full cabin. He would say a bunk was sure to be freed up the next night, but he always ended up finding a passenger to fill any vacancy. When the weather was as bad as this, the mules could not be left out at a hitch post. They slept inside the makeshift stable on the deck, with me alongside them as Piggy had promised.
One night, as I lay curled on the straw, smelling the mules and feeling drips of rain on my face, I heard, underneath the sound of the storm, an irritating squeaking: The Baron’s wheels. Then, the click of his little nails on wood. I sat up. The Baron had somehow escaped his lush bed and found his way to me. I had a strange urge to hold him. I lifted my damp blanket and tried to gather him up. But as soon as he was in my arms, he nipped my wrist and wriggled free.
All the anger I had been trying to keep down, all that was rotten and wicked that had lain dormant in my bowels, roiled up, twisting my stomach and burning my throat. I lunged at the dog and picked him up. I went out to the deck and climbed to the roof, the dog almost slipping from my hands. We were soaked through in seconds. I wiped the water from my eyes and met The Baron’s gaze, finding only a terrible blankness. He made no sound. From the roof of the boat, I hurled The Baron into the canal.
It took only the sound of his splash to make me regret what I’d done, and without hesitation, I dove in after him. I felt I might perish from the shock of the cold. There in the quiet of the water, dark shadows moved all around me, and I suddenly wondered if my family had tried at all to look for me after I left those months ago. When I surfaced again, the cacophony of the storm rang in my head. The rain pelted me and the wind slapped water into my face and mouth. I saw The Baron swirling away, caught up in a current that had been forged by the storm. I thrashed my arms and legs, tore at the water with a crazed fervor as I tried to reach the animal. I got close enough that I grasped one of his yellow ribbons, but it slid off his body and through my fingers. Its sodden texture frightened me, reminded me of the man in the lock, and I screamed and shook it from my hand, choking on more water.
I saw a boy, surely another mule driver, out for a late-night amble along the towpath, and I yelled to him as best I could. He took off running and shouting about a drowning boy, and boatmen came out on the decks to see what was happening. Soon they were racing after me, thinking I had fallen overboard. They dipped poles into the water so that I might grab onto them, but I continued after The Baron. When I reached him, he was tangled up in a rope, a frayed and rotted towline a green mule boy had surely dropped ages ago. His claws scratched my forearms as I tried to free him, and finally I was able to seize The Baron in one arm. But soon as I did, I found my own foot caught, lodged between the stone wall of the canal and something metal at the very bottom. I tried to shake myself loose, but my foot was all sealed up in my weighty, waterlogged shoe, thoroughly captured. It was as though all the water’s sludge and debris had turned animate and was pulling me into the canal’s underworld. Panic rippled inside me, but I did not want to risk releasing The Baron and losing him for good. With renewed vigor, I turned my ankle back and forth and eventually slithered my foot from my shoe. The Baron and I floated away from the wall almost serenely.
A few men ran down to the towpath to fish us out. Panting and gagging, I placed The Baron gently on the ground. He shook his fur out, paused, turned, and tottered away from me. He had not so much as yelped during the whole ordeal. Suddenly, the men were pounding me on the back, commending me for my bravery in saving the helpless little dog. They were shouting and cheering by the time they’d walked me to Beekman’s boat, one of them holding The Baron, whom I couldn’t look at, much less carry. It seemed everyone on the canal had come out in the rain to see the commotion. Beekman listened, bleary-eyed, as the men spoke of my heroic actions and shoved The Baron into his arms. Piggy slept through it all.
————
We reached the terminus by the end of the week. Festivities were held, as always, at the Mayes Tavern and Inn, a bar for boatmen. I had become something of a mascot the past few days. The news of my rescuing The Baron had spread. I was praised so thoroughly I started to believe my own worth. I searched around for Isaac, having still not yet relayed the story to him, but could not find him. Surely he was tucked away somewhere composing his sermon. It was, at first, the greatest night of my life. I had taken a reprieve from my temperance. Where I was used to sneaking sips here and there, the men at the tavern were now buying me mugs of golden beer. There was raucous chatter, fiddle music, the crackle of fire.
“That I should have to pay a nickel just to see the falls in the very town where I was born!” shouted the barmaid at a group of boatmen, who cheered on her indignation.
I was swirling drunk, singing and laughing, clapping men on the back twice my age and height. I slammed my glass against their glasses so that beer cascaded down the sides in joyful waste. It hardly seemed possible, but in one corner of the bar was a caged, living bear. I stood, wavering from side to side, and watched the bear saunter to and fro in its minuscule enclosure, wondering if it was some kind of illusion.
I climbed the steps to the boarding rooms, swinging with great cheer around every curve in the bannister. Beekman was sleeping at the inn that night, and I had come to collect my earnings for the season so far.
He sat at a small wooden desk, not meeting my eyes. Piggy was behind him on the bed, clutching The Baron and scowling at me. I prepared to modestly acknowledge my courage and accept any suitable bonus.
“This is all I can offer you,” Beekman said, sliding a few dimes in my direction. I was supposed to earn eleven dollars in total.
I stood there, looking at the meager coins between us, too stunned to speak.
Beekman carried on, making marks in some ledger, “I know what you’ve done.”
“We know what you’ve done,” Piggy corrected from behind him.
My face turned hot.
“Garfield’s boy Isaac saw you, what you did to The Baron.”
Shards of glass caught in my throat. I stood silently until I finally managed a few words. “But—I saved him too.”
“You should be happy you received a cent from us at all.” Piggy turned The Baron away from me and toward her breast.
I grabbed the coins off the desk and dashed from the room.
————
Where was Isaac? I asked each person in the taproom and then asked again. Of the few that knew him, none knew his whereabouts. I circled the room feverishly, stumbling over a small stool that I then kicked into the fireplace. Finally, I settled for a long while in a threadbare armchair with my face in my hands. When I lifted my head again, Isaac
was standing before my chair. It was Isaac who had found me. Startled, I got to my feet.
“Why’d you tell Beekman that? You know he’s not giving me my wages now?”
“You tried to kill an innocent creature,” he said, smiling slightly at me with a blend of scorn and pity. His expression was unbearably penetrating. He knew exactly how wicked I was.
I wanted to say what’d I said to Beekman, that it was also I who had saved The Baron’s life. Instead, I said something unintelligible about his velvet bed, Piggy slapping my hand.
“She was feeding him bacon!” I cried. But the words were so paltry compared to what I felt.
Isaac suddenly dropped to his knees before me, taking my hands in his own. “Ask for Beekman’s forgiveness,” he said, the reflection of firelight writhing in his pale irises. “Choose to make things right.”
I wanted to believe him that I could. If I got Beekman and Piggy to forgive me, perhaps Isaac might see me afresh too. I was about to ask him what I should do when he spoke again.
“Come to the revival tomorrow.” His smile was kinder now. “I intend to tell the story of these events in my sermon.”
I pulled my hands away sharply.
“So all the world can think me some dog-drowner?”
“No!” He looked truly shocked, obviously expecting that I would be flattered. “So they may see you repent!”
I stood again, shoved past Isaac, and ran from the bar. I walked and wept for a long time and must have slept somewhere in the dirt that night, though I thankfully remember little. As I wandered the port the next day, I thought briefly of going to the revival and doing as Isaac wanted. Perhaps being of use to him was as near to being a friend as I could get. But I stayed away, whether from anger at him or shame at myself I still cannot be sure. I did not visit the falls, as you might have guessed. I don’t care to tell the story of how I made my way back to the farm, but it involved weeks of travel and work, both terrifying and dangerous and interminably dull.
————
That canal season wove itself easily into my distant memories. I thought of it for a while in great bitterness, and then even that dulled. Some version of the events became an anecdote I told in bars, with no mention of Isaac at all. The miserable little dog, with an underbite and ribbons in his fur, became a character in tales I invented to amuse my wife, and later my son and daughter. I am a railroad brakeman, and like all the wives of brakemen, mine wishes me to find less dangerous work, work that doesn’t take me so far so often. It is true that I once almost plummeted from the top of a moving train trying to slow the cars, that I lost the tip of my pinky finger in a coupling accident, that I miss them fiercely when I’m gone. I have seen more of the country and met more of its inhabitants than I ever thought possible. I went all the way to Chicago and sent them a postcard. I tried to explain that it is these very misfortunes and adventures which make returning all the sweeter. Like tonight, when I opened the door to our home and breathed its smell, clutching a newspaper a passenger had left on a seat. The front page announced the winner of a close mayoral race in Albany. Though I never knew Isaac’s surname, I was shocked at how easily I recognized his face, even after twenty-five years, from the engraving above the article. I felt a strange pride, infused with resentment: I had known the new mayor of Albany when we were boys. As I read, I learned that Isaac had not been an orphan at all. His father, in addition to serving as a director of the Atlantic Telegraph Company, had also been the mayor some years before, probably the very summer Isaac and I had met. I could not remember why I had judged him to be an orphan. Like those childhood beliefs rarely reconsidered, it had just stuck until now. I thought he’d make a fine enough mayor. I looked around, thinking I should tell someone what I learned, but my family was asleep, and there was no one I knew who would understand the meaning of all this. Moments from that canal season swarmed my mind like gnats: Isaac’s face lit up by the fire, Beekman’s writhing body, The Baron swirling away in stormy waters, the Leaper emerging from the base of the falls. I felt a reordering happening inside me, quiet and quick. I was flooded with affection for the boy I had been. I thought of Samson and Delilah and wondered how many seasons they worked after I had driven them, knowing they must be long dead. I thought of the forelock that swung over Samson’s eyes, blinding him to everything but the next step in front of him, and then the next.
Sally DeWind is a writer and English teacher from Brooklyn, New York.