It was shortsighted of me to invite Eduardo to move in because he was so good-looking. I lived in Echo Park with a dreamy view of the skyrises in downtown LA, an apartment I could afford only because the landlord was an older Croatian woman who didn’t know about online marketing. Aside from the horrendous roach problem—they seethed from the kitchen outlets—it was a perfect apartment. Two bedrooms, two full baths, on the second floor of a fourplex. Lacquered wood floors, central air, a courtyard shaded with jacaranda trees, hummingbirds all year long. My friend Hannah and I populated the place with succulents and secondhand furniture along with things men seemed to keep giving Hannah because she was a great beauty who worked for an art dealer downtown. I asked Hannah if she felt beholden to these lavish, gift-giving men.
“I don’t feel beholden to anyone,” she said, running her hand along our new Danish teak dining table.
Two months later, Hannah met a traveling architect and moved after him to Brooklyn, proving her point. She left behind her giant’s bed and the Danish table. So, as the leaseholder of fine real estate, tastefully furnished, I’d had my pick of potential roommates.
I enjoyed the roommate search. Kind strangers opened up about cat allergies, noise tolerance, their projected number of sleepovers. The conversations quickly became intimate. One applicant read my palm when he came over. “Oh, interesting,” he said, holding my hand. He told me I could expect “deep psychic trouble” that year but that I’d be fine, “eventually.” Then the palm reader said that he and I would not be roommates. Why not? Was it the psychic trouble? It was there in my palm, he said. Plus, he didn’t care for the bedroom, which had only the one window, looking out on the narrow side alley.
Eduardo was an obvious choice. A friend of friends at school, he brought no furniture and very few possessions. Like me, he was a doctoral student. He was on a student visa from Uruguay. We were both twenty-nine when he signed the lease. We got on well from the start, and he had an improving influence on me. We talked about our reading and our professors, and I learned to better articulate my thoughts, which had been a problem. I sometimes went mute in graduate seminars. Eduardo mostly ate raw foods. At night we’d crunch through bowls of beet and carrot slaw, and in time, my skin shone like a new penny.
Admittedly, he was also a minor slob and a bit prideful about it. He produced more dirty glasses than we had in the cupboard and left his books straddled on the backs of chairs, so he might return to a page. He acted as if caring about the state of the apartment conceded a poverty of mind.
I might have been irked when he came home while I was beating the couch cushions on the balcony and shook his head pityingly. “There’s just so much else you could be doing,” he said.
But it was a kind of spell I was under. I viewed it as an opportunity to consider my conditioning as a woman. Eventually, I made a list of chores for us like a schoolteacher, which Eduardo agreed to. I later learned he grew up with maids.
————
One day, as I was checking out at our neighborhood coffee shop, I noticed a goldfish bowl had appeared on the counter that advertised a raffle. It appeared to be a joke. “Win a ride with Evangeline,” a sign said. Taped to the face of the bowl was a bikini-clad blonde woman sitting on the hood of a car. A pink bikini, pink convertible, and pink sunglasses. The woman held her ams up to the camera in a V. The hairstyle, a teased platinum pouf on top, placed the photo somewhere in the middle ’80s.
It helps to understand that the baristas were freaks. Well-read punks who were often surly and sometimes hilarious. I held up a little square of paper on which one was supposed to write one’s name and number.
“Is this a gag?” I asked. “This raffle?”
It’s very serious,” he said. He set my mug down and looked at me through his blue-rimmed glasses, his expression flat and unreadable. “Evangeline’s calling it a lottery.”
That he was on a first-name basis with the woman in the old photo was a surprise, but it didn’t clear up for me what might happen if you dropped your name and number in the bowl, or what you were hoping to win.
Then Eduardo won the lottery. He told me so in the kitchen while we ate dinner salads. He was seated on the countertop, swinging his legs. I was trying to figure out what we’d do about us and the fact that just the week before, we’d slept together. Eduardo had been slightly more affectionate since. He might touch my shoulder to get my attention. He invited my feet onto his lap while we read on the living room couch. He actually licked his thumb that morning to smooth the blush on my cheek. I’ve always been hopeless with makeup but was newly inspired to apply it before plodding down the hall for my coffee. The new shape of our cohabitation was uncharted. I was happy to let it—whatever it was—unfold on its own terms.
As he sat on the countertop, Eduardo played with the bathroom door with his foot, opening and closing it. Eduardo looked vital and futuristic. He had a modish haircut that reminded me of an old sci-fi film. It was a moment when LA fashion felt outer-space themed. He dressed loudly in bright patterns but was a quiet person.
“I got an interesting call today,” he said.
He wanted me to ask what about. He’d won the lottery, he said.
“I’m surprised, first, that this lottery wasn’t just a goof,” I said. “Second, I can’t believe you put your name in.”
In truth, it didn’t seem out of character. Eduardo prided himself on finding interest anywhere. One Sunday morning, while we were drinking coffee, he asked me to go with him to the church service across the street at Iglesia Evangelica Latina.
“Absolutely not,” I said. “I spent every Sunday of my childhood bored in church.”
“I always wondered what the colonizer’s religion was all about.”
“I don’t need to go,” I said.
He shrugged, then he went to change. When I heard him leaving, I found myself chasing after him.
We sat through the service in our nice clothes, which was livelier than the Episcopal services of my youth. I felt uncomfortable ogling other people’s relationship to mystery. The golden chalice and dusty hymnals, the old incantatory language, creating enough distance from real life to slow us down, like poetry does. Then the children’s chorus performed, and Eduardo grabbed my knee. It was like heaven was rolling out of their open mouths. Afterward, we shook hands with everybody. The service gave Eduardo an idea for a conference paper.
“The woman, Evangeline, told me that her assistant just got married,” Eduardo said. “She said she didn’t usually call the winners herself.”
That sounded like a lie to me, but Eduardo seemed pleasantly surprised by the whole thing anyway.
“So you’re going on a drive, then? The two of you in her pink convertible?”
“Friday,” he said. “Maybe I’ll interview her. The more I learn about her, the more I want to know.”
Eduardo was in Cinema Studies at my school, as a scholar, not a filmmaker, but he had a closet full of camera equipment that he kept saying he was going to use. Eduardo’s younger brother was a successful music video director, which was a source of torment for Eduardo. He thought his brother’s ass-shaking videos were vapid and embarrassing. Eduardo wanted to make important work and so ended up making nothing at all. We were both wading through the nebulous years of writing our dissertations. I was considering classes in TV writing though I’d been studying Victorian literature for six years.
“Eduardo, you won’t let this woman make a fool of herself on camera, will you? Like, look at the sad, D-list celebrity? You’re not going to make her into a joke?”
“Why do you think she’s a joke?”
“Oh, come on,” I said.
“She ran for mayor, you know.”
“Stop. She did not.”
“She got like ten percent of the vote.”
“That’s just depressing.”
“She has a genius for self-promotion.”
He was making me look bad, or I was making myself look bad, which was annoying, and it made me want to double down. “Don’t be coy,” I said. “Some people can’t talk about their experiences in interesting ways.”
He’d made me say an ugly thing, and he had a prim, self-satisfied smile. It was a brotherly way of flirting.
“I kind of want to go now too,” I said. “Can I come?”
“Definitely not,” he said.
————
It isn’t comfortable to wake up thinking of someone you share a wall with. Eduardo had a thoughtful, private expression but gave you his full, considered attention. He walked with his insteps forward, toes outturned, the way clowns walked in films. The reason seemed anatomical, not that I’d ever asked. Regardless, he sauntered. He was confidently unhurried, and it suited him. Unlike me, he never lost sleep over his studies. In fact, he seemed not to care much about the dissertation chapter he was preparing, or the nitpicking, distinguished professor he had to send it to. I tend to revere the things I struggle with. And I loved the way he said my name, drawing out the first syllable, so it became “Lauw-rah.”
When our sleeping together did not become a regular occurrence, I thought this was our careful way of entering something weightier. The night we had sex, I had come home to find Eduardo tending a lentil stew. He poured me a glass of the wine he was drinking before asking if I wanted one. He seemed stirred up—not that he’d been crying, but he was wistful. He missed Montevideo.
He told me he’d talked to his mother earlier. She had been chopping onions for the lentil stew she always made when someone fell ill. Who was ill? he’d wanted to know. “I have bronchitis,” she said. It was like her to deliver information this way. So carefully dramatic. All her children had fled to other continents. Eduardo’s father was always gone. Eduardo wasn’t worried about the bronchitis, but it pained him that if something did happen to her, he would be so far away. We finished that bottle of wine and opened another.
As we ate the stew, and as he was making a point about something, he touched my arm for emphasis. My insides jolted awake. I’m sure my face lit up. Then he didn’t move his hand away.
The sex we had that night felt like a practice run. I could not look Eduardo in the eyes during the act, and especially not in the more eventful moments. And afterward, rather than sleep together in the same bed, we went to the twenty-four-hour Korean spa. It was 3 a.m. This had been Eduardo’s suggestion, but was it a romantic one? We arrived at an exhaust-gray building in Koreatown. The lobby air smelled chlorinated like a community pool.
Inside, the spa was a marvel of colored lights and sauna domes made of stacked white stones, each with its own temperature and healing properties. People lay on mats, sleeping. At thirty dollars a ticket, the spa offered a savings over a hotel room.
Our spa-issued uniform was a pair of saffron drawstring shorts and an oversized T-shirt, and it struck me that we looked like gym classmates, or siblings. In a way, Eduardo was like my brother. I felt closer to him than my real brother, anyway, and I still wanted to have sex with him. I felt I had discovered a rare and wonderful thing in this combination of ease and attraction.
Eduardo and I ducked into the jade sauna. In the bath-water air, we lay side by side on mats, our heads on vinyl pillows. Eduardo held my hand. We shared our dome with a man snoring consistently and peacefully. This and the darkness of the dome allowed us to talk freely again.
He was, at that moment, running a finger up and down my arm, but in the least sensual way possible. I am not unattractive, I should mention. If I was good-looking, it was in my own austere, horse-boned way. I was sure I was single because I’d spent too much time thinking about things that very few people found worthwhile. And not because I was shy and rarely went out.
“You know,” I said, trying to be as mature as I could. “If you want to say tonight exists outside of time, that’s okay. This doesn’t have to mean anything.”
“Laura, Laura, Laura,” he said, drawing out that syllable. “But I want it to mean something.”
I was relieved. In fact, maybe I was euphoric. Except, I was hoping he’d tell me more precisely what he wanted it to mean. We lay together in the near dark, and I waited for him to go on. It wasn’t a hot sauna. The air was so warm and moist it was like breath. As I waited, I listened to the man’s rumbling snore until I, too, fell asleep.
We were pruned to hell in the morning. The spa thrummed to life in a multitude of languages. People rolled in, young and old, in their sexless spa uniforms. We ate fermented vegetables in the spa cafeteria. A precocious boy asked the cafeteria worker if the dumplings could be steamed, not fried. Bless that boy’s healthy little heart. It seemed the world had veered utopian overnight.
————
Shortly after Eduardo moved in, he told me he was in love with a married woman in Uruguay, someone older. But he said it so casually I got the impression this was a forever-love rooted in childhood. I assumed from the start he wasn’t attracted to me. His gaze did not linger on my face or drop to my lips. I never caught him examining my body, no matter my state of undress. So I did not spend our year together lusting after him. But when we’d crossed that threshold, I didn’t know how to act, and our living together became a gauntlet of kind rejection I pretended not to care about.
Eduardo and I continued to go on excursions, despite this—to see the congregation of low riders in Elysian Park, to the coast for cool air and fish tacos, to Chinatown for dim sum, to Pasadena to hear a famed sitar player. He was thoughtful and generous. If he was making a cup of tea, he always poured two. He is the only person I’ve met who liked to drink martinis, a fancy he picked up from American movies. But he could not extend this romance to television. He hated how much we Americans talked about television.
“You’re all obsessed with TV and cars,” he said, “and teeth.”
“Teeth?” I said.
“No one here has normal teeth.”
“I have normal teeth!” I grimaced to expose my full set.
“No,” he said, and shocked me by tapping on my canine. “You’ve got those perfect Chiclet teeth.”
His teasing and his snobberies were part of his charm and foundational to the ease I felt around him. He could tell me that my dissertation chapter was boring. He said that I ought to invest in new pants, which I did. He laughed when I said something dumb, and it did not sting me. In fact, venturing a dumb remark became easier and more survivable. We went for many long walks through the neighborhood, and when I think about one of the great pulls for me, it was that Eduardo acquainted me with a hunger to be more in the world than I was, shuttling between school and the apartment and the coffee shop in a haze of self-focused worry. Then he went on his drive with Evangeline.
————
When Eduardo did not come home the night of his drive, I looked Evangeline up. She was more interesting than I’d allowed. She had emigrated from Ukraine as a teen. She had played in a punk band in the early ’80s, styled as a raunchy Debbie Harry. Then, she rented billboards around LA and put up pictures of herself on top of a pink convertible in a bikini. Her name, Evangeline, was scrawled below. The billboard campaign lasted a couple of years and launched her as a local celebrity. She released a solo album. She created a fan club and sent her dues-paying members autographed pink souvenirs. In the early aughts, she ran for mayor of LA as a publicity stunt, despite having no agenda whatsoever. It was all so tacky, it might have been performance art.
The next morning, I was on the couch pretending to read when Eduardo returned. He walked in smiling at me, said good morning, and sat himself down at the table in the living room. He stretched his long arms overhead sleepily and groaned.
I, too, stretched my arms overhead as if I’d just woken up. I tried to sound light when I said, “Tell me you didn’t sleep with that woman.”
I’d almost said “that old woman.” I didn’t, but it didn’t seem to matter. The word old was silent but present.
“I didn’t sleep with that woman.” He said it so tonelessly that it was clear he objected to the question.
So he had slept with her. I had not seriously factored that possibility into my jealousy.
Evangeline had seemed so far outside the realm of women he might be attracted to. As a woman in her fifties, she could have been Eduardo’s mother, and she was vain and fame hungry. It didn’t make sense.
We talked shallowly about our plans for the day. Me, a word count goal and papers to grade. Him, lesson planning and an afternoon nap. All the while, I pleaded silently for reassurance that he had really stayed elsewhere, on a friend’s couch. He acted as though principle kept him from saying either way. He rolled out his neck until I could have throttled him.
“I am more than just your meddling roommate,” I said, as if saying this would make it so. Eduardo went to his room.
For the next couple of days, we moved politely about the apartment. I told my friends what upset me was that Eduardo was not communicating with me. I didn’t care if we weren’t exclusive. We didn’t establish ground rules for our thing. I just wanted to have a productive discussion about it, so no feelings were hurt. When I explained this to my friends, they winced with concern.
Meanwhile, Eduardo unpacked his film equipment from his closet and took it to Evangeline’s. He was making a film after all. I pretended not to notice. I didn’t ask about it. It was my one real capitulation to jealousy. Slowly, he was gone half the week, and then most of the week, and this began to feel normal.
Eduardo and I had a text thread—mostly goofs between us—which had a few genres, all inscrutable (and unfunny) to outsiders. Pictures of favorite advertisements on bus 86 from downtown to Echo Park. Bits of mental dialogue. An eavesdropping series from the bus. Questions posed to the void. It was our version of Twitter. Anyway, Eduardo stopped texting, and he replied, only, “Ha!”
I was losing interest in my dissertation. There were no academic jobs to be had, anyway, so the point of the work became finishing a difficult task I had begun out of principle. I vacillated between a week of diligent writing and then not opening the files on my computer for weeks. I taught freshman composition at the university on Tuesdays and Thursdays, which gave my life a small sense of purpose and a little structure. Largely, I felt adrift and more than a little foolish. On Facebook, I saw my friends from college having children, having dental insurance, having a life I’d once thought boring and then suddenly wanted for myself.
For a month or two, I wallowed in self-pity. I haunted our apartment at night, missing the excursions I used to take with Eduardo and turning down invitations from other friends. When Eduardo did come by, I watched myself try to punish him by being no fun at all, choosing to read in my room instead of walking to the taco stand.
Eventually, of course, I got on with things and downloaded the dating apps. I began dating aggressively, two coffee dates a week, which is how I met Dan. Easy, even-keeled, kindhearted Dan, who liked arcade bars and was in the writers’ room for a sitcom I hadn’t heard of. Dan was slightly older than me at thirty-six, but we jibed immediately. What a relief to enter a dark bar on Alvarado and to be laughing before my first drink arrived. My new relationship eased the tension with Eduardo at the apartment. Because I was happy again, and could talk about my date the night before, Eduardo felt free to tell me about his vision for the film and about Evangeline, whom he spoke of with exasperation and fondness. He seemed to be having the good, miserable time he’d been after.
————
I’d been dating Dan for three months when Eduardo invited us to brunch with Evangeline. Dan had to cancel a regular rock-climbing appointment with friends, and I couldn’t quite explain to him the importance of the brunch or why I wanted him to be there. No, it wasn’t a double date, exactly, I said. This is a woman who is the subject of my roommate’s film.
“But you don’t sound like you actually like this woman,” he said, “so I just don’t get it.”
“It’s for Eduardo,” I said. “He’s been working on this for months.”
“And his film—a documentary?”
“I don’t know,” I said. “Maybe a documentary in the Chris Marker sense—one of those films that has a through-line just so it can be about everything. An essay film.”
Dan made the face I expected him to make. He isn’t a good audience for films like that and maybe that’s something I liked about him. His “industry” outlook was grounding for me. It gave me something to rail against. He admired artistry without needing films to be art, and he had very little tolerance for pretensions he didn’t share. As far as politics went, he was a “work with the system” guy. He had a reasonably good relationship with his liberal, Jewish parents, and he cooked. He introduced me to latkes. What a delight, latkes. I was a little disappointed in myself for wanting the conventionality that partnering with Dan would mean—when my LA friends were increasingly polyamorous and queer.
————
It was a beautiful morning in LA, and I had reason to celebrate. I had been given another year of funding by the graduate school. A year I intended to spend looking for other means of supporting myself as I finished my dissertation. Dan and I walked through that balmy morning to the restaurant and were seated right away on the patio. A great sweep of bougainvillea bloomed orange and pink overhead, announcing summer on its way.
I’d devoted quite a bit of my free time over the months to thinking about Evangeline, and now, at long last, I’d meet her. Eduardo and Evangeline were running late, of course.
The diners on the patio turned to watch a pink convertible sail around the corner. Eduardo threw me a peace sign as they passed. They headed up the hill to find parking in the neighborhood. Evangeline was at the wheel, her face covered by dark sunglasses.
Dan turned to me, laughing. “I forgot about the car.”
We heard her clicking heels on the sidewalk approaching before we saw them, and it seemed the conversations around us stalled when they came into view. Evangeline’s voluminous silver-blonde hair fell in curled tresses to the middle of her back. Her lipstick, halter dress, and pumps were a matching bubble-gum pink. She wore a leopard-print bomber jacket over her dress.
Eduardo, for his part, wore all white, down to his canvas shoes, a backdrop that would make her stand out. The contrast established them visually as a couple, and I recalled he had been wearing white more when he came by the apartment, often only to study.
The two seemed to have been bickering before they arrived. They moved together tensely, as if something cutting had just been said.
Eduardo rushed up, kissed my cheek, put a hand on Dan’s shoulder, very familiarly, though they’d only had the briefest acquaintance, and said, “I’m sorry we’re late. She hit a pigeon just now.”
“You said you wouldn’t!” she said, catching up, her voice high and melodious, with a slight accent.
“But how?” I said. “They’re so slow.”
“It was awful,” she said, grabbing my hand in greeting. “But he acts like I meant to do it!”
Eduardo pulled out her chair for her, and she came to sit slowly, like a balloon floating to the ground.
“But if there’s no remorse,” Eduardo said, “what does it matter, accident or no accident?”
“He’s so sensitive,” she said, giving a colluding smile. “The sensitive director.”
She perched her glasses above her fringe, revealing her green eyes. Her teeth gleamed white, porcelain veneers. She clearly had had some work done on her face, Botox and fillers and such, but it had all been done in the ways that the Hollywood people do it, so it was not her youthful face preserved but a new design. She was a beautiful woman. What did I expect? She was a tenth the size of the woman who’d glowered seductively at the cars of Sunset Boulevard, but she was no less glamorous. She seemed to notice my close inspection, and I looked away, ashamed.
“Well, I’ll order the vegetarian option,” Dan said. “One pigeon for one fried chicken. We’ll call it even with karma.”
“I see that you are telling a joke,” Eduardo said, “but the chicken is already dead whether you eat it or not.”
“Really,” Dan said, hand on his chest, “it’s my sacrifice.”
Dan swerved the conversation, and I couldn’t have been more grateful. “Evangeline, that convertible you drove up in—that looks like a car that’s got a name.”
“It should have a name!” she said. “People just love that car, especially outside of LA. You can’t shock anybody in LA. They’ve seen it all. It’s my fourth one in I don’t know how many years. You ought to be my new publicist.”
“I’d love it, truly, but they keep me busy on the show.”
Dan talked about his job in the writers’ room with the same self-deprecation that charmed me on our first date. “I’m not the funniest writer by a long shot, but everybody likes me. I don’t make a fuss. And so I keep getting jobs.”
Eduardo had been listening to Dan and gave me a teasing look. Eduardo and Dan would never have been friends in the wild, but I sensed his approval. I hadn’t known I’d wanted this approval. But there it was.
“Laura’s terrible at describing this film you’re making,” Dan said. “I asked her, and she said it was a film about everything.”
“It’s about Evangeline!” I protested.
“You could say it’s inspired by Evangeline,” Eduardo said. “It’s about identity in the United States as an immigrant. Or trying to assimilate to a place by becoming a caricature of it. Evangeline’s career plays with that, I think. The punk band and the billboards.”
“Sounds like you’re calling Evangeline a cartoon,” Dan said.
“He would call me a cartoon,” she said.
“Nothing like that. That would mean you don’t have agency. You’re too smart for that.”
She smiled.
“And I have veto power, of course,” Evangeline said. “I’d be the first to say I didn’t know what I was doing when I arrived here. This place wants to snuff you out. It wants to drown you. You have to be very tough as a girl.”
Both men nodded their agreement. There we were, having a nice civil brunch on a lovely morning. Eduardo topped off our coffees, beginning with Evangeline’s cup, a small gesture of care. I felt awash in disappointment that I could not put my finger on.
She talked openly about the business of being Evangeline—the invitations for collabs she fielded weekly and her decision to stay off OnlyFans—and the homelife I was so curious about: her Yorkie’s nighttime antics, some trouble with the Jacuzzi-tub jets, the trip they planned to make to Vegas. And still this combination of details did not yield up the complete picture of her for me—nor of Eduardo, who’d chosen her over me. Because I wanted to know if Eduardo was in this relationship because it was advantageous for his art, and I still didn’t know. Though she was perfectly nice, Evangeline seemed as unknowable as a foreign city through the airport glass on a layover. All the while, despite my scrutiny, Evangeline performed a magic trick by eating her omelet without ever seeming to take a bite of it. The omelet whittled itself away on her plate as she sat there like a lady above it.
When our conversation landed back on the fine weather, Evangeline refolded the napkin in her lap to alert Eduardo to the fact we were wrapping up. He straightened, and his voice took on that “well, this has been . . .” tone.
We walked with them to her car, and there in the middle of the street was the pigeon she’d hit before parking. They’re huge, pigeons, and this one, spread out indignantly with its lovely iridescent neck askew, stretched more than a foot from wingtip to wingtip. In the abstract, the fact of its death was too bad, but on the pavement, she’d turned it into meat. Evangeline slid on her sunglasses.
“I’m sending a teaser of the film to Netflix this week,” Eduardo said. “A hookup from my brother. I have a lot of editing to do.”
“But why didn’t you mention it earlier?”
Eduardo shrugged. “It’s probably nothing. I’m just telling you that I’ll be around the apartment more the next few days.”
I shoved him. “You’re such a big, proud dope.”
Eduardo loved that. Evangeline started the engine, and she blew us a kiss goodbye before she ascended the hill and left our lives forever.
————
Dan and I walked to my apartment past the gorgeous old Victorian houses that—a hundred years before—had been moved by horseback from downtown to this hill. Back then, Dan told me, this hill had been in the country. He liked to read about the city’s history.
“The thing about Eduardo is that he has things both ways,” I said.
“His relationship with her is a joke, and it isn’t at the same time.”
“You seem to care a lot about it,” he said.
“I just don’t understand what he’s doing!”
I never told Dan that I’d slept with Eduardo. It wouldn’t have been a big deal. There was so little to tell—we slept together and then realized we were just friends—but I did not tell him for so long it became a secret I was keeping from him. It was never the right moment to come clean, and I could not explain why I’d not mentioned it sooner.
“He doesn’t know how to talk about what he’s making yet,” Dan said.
“And maybe that’s okay. There’s no money in documentary filmmaking anyway. It’s a passion project.”
I hated that he said that even if I agreed with him.
“Are you coming over tonight?” he asked.
“Yes,” I said, but he needn’t have asked. We’d reached a stage in couplehood when spending the night together became the expectation, and more often than not, I would sleep at his. Dan didn’t need a roommate to make rent. He had matching furniture that he’d bought new. He had a dishwasher. He had functional blinds and a robotic vacuum. He had subscriptions to every movie channel you could think of. His showerhead played NPR in the morning. Don’t get me started on his bedding. It wasn’t a stylish apartment—Dan wasn’t stylish—but it was a good deal more comfortable for two.
More significant than his thread count was that Dan looked at me that way anyone hopes to be looked at. We both knew what it meant. We were barreling toward long-term commitment.
We settled into a kind of routine, Eduardo spending more time at Evangeline’s as I spent more time at Dan’s. Our apartment became like a shared office. I might come home to find Eduardo bent over work at the kitchen table, and he’d smile up at me, glad to see me home. I’d put the kettle on, and we’d catch up. Things were easy between us again, intimate even, but our run-ins were getting rarer. One night, a few months later, Dan had had too much to drink. We were eating Halloween candy in bed. He said, “One of these days I’m going to ask you a question, and if you don’t want that, you better tell me now.”
I told Eduardo I would be moving out. The apartment was his.
————
I gave Eduardo two months’ notice, but he was preoccupied then with his own good news. Through an email chain (who knows how these things happen), it was discovered that the actor Sean Penn remembered Evangeline’s billboards back in the eighties, and the Netflix people were keen to see if the actor would take on a producing role. Just the name— Sean Penn—would suddenly make the film valuable. Netflix would buy in. In my final weeks at the apartment, as I was packing up my things, Eduardo was there, too, often pacing around the living room and waiting on a phone call from somebody. A dinner was in the works—Eduardo and Sean Penn at Evangeline’s house—but the actor’s schedule kept changing. Eduardo’s brother, Juan, called often to offer advice.
I still hadn’t seen any footage from his film. Eduardo wanted to wait until there was more to show. When I told him he was being precious, he said that it was my opinion that mattered most of all. That thing about his walk—his saunter—it now seemed to me a stamp of good fortune. I could imagine him successful, and he appeared to be trying it on. I wondered how Evangeline felt about Eduardo’s retreat to our apartment.
I told Eduardo that I would leave most of my furniture. I said that if things didn’t work out between me and Dan, I wanted to move right back in without a hitch. It was bittersweet, boxing up my books, knowing things between us would change after I left. I’ve always believed that friendship is really one of the few sustaining aspects of life, as primary to well-being as having someone to bed down with. But Eduardo and I—we wouldn’t have coffee dates. We wouldn’t chat on the phone. Our friendship required proximity.
It was a kind of end for us, which meant, in the month I spent packing up, Eduardo was more handsy. With an end in sight, we goofed around more. We watched films at night, films that would hold no interest for Dan. The night we watched La Strada, we sat on the couch with our legs intertwined. I wouldn’t have wanted Dan to see us like that, but because nothing else would happen, I didn’t think it mattered much. The end of La Strada killed us. If there was a god of art, we were prepared to fall down and start worshipping. It’s a corny film, mostly, but in the final scene, you feel these larger forces at work closing in on the protagonist, and though he’s a villain and deserves it, you sense the crushing indifference of the world to a person’s fate. He’s having a reckoning, and he’s bawling. This man who seemed to have the emotional intelligence of a child. And if you’re us—you feel what he’s feeling, and you’re grateful to feel that devastated, as though you’ve seen something, though unpleasant, that is real and true. We held each other and cried, and it was only comical if you weren’t us at that moment. But we were almost in love, Eduardo and I. Eduardo was the person whom I was closest to in the world, besides Dan.
Eduardo made us tea, then, and we sat cross-legged on the couch and talked the magic out of the film. Eduardo said, “You know, I don’t even know what happened with us. I always thought we were about to get serious.”
“With us?” It was just like him to say that, looking meaningfully into my eyes, willfully clueless. “Well, you won the lottery,” I said. I twirled my hand. “Fate intercedes.”
“That’s true,” he said, as if it was a regrettable fact. He picked up his phone, which had been buzzing on the coffee table. The screen was lit with text messages from Evangeline. The last was just a row of question marks. He set the phone down before he’d thought of a response.
“Does she know that we were,” I said, “involved?”
He smiled. “She imagined we were from the start, right when she heard my roommate was a woman. But she thinks I’m trying to sleep with everyone in the world. I finally said she had to meet you and Dan, so she’d stop talking about it. I guess it’s no surprise that she’s possessive.”
“No surprise,” I said. I was knee-to-knee with Eduardo. He’d been tapping my shin. It baffled me that I could so quickly skate over the weeks I spent wallowing to arrive again at that buoyant feeling for him. “But what is it, though, your attraction to her? You’ve never said why.”
“She’s a beautiful woman,” he said.
“Right, obviously,” I said. “But attraction is more than beauty.”
“I know how she seems. Evangeline is the center of her own universe. She confuses feeling strongly about something with being unassailably right. Everyone else is simply in her orbit. She’s deeply strange and knows it.”
“Deeply strange?”
“She collects things—art, dolls, teacups.”
“Teacups,” I said, imagining the footage of her teacup collection. The interview with the maid who dusts them.
“But she’s fun—really. She’s more than eccentric. If it is her universe, it’s a fun one to be swept up in for a while.” Eduardo had hardly finished telling me how fun Evangeline was before his phone buzzed again. He had to laugh about it.
“I need to find more moving boxes,” I said, surveying the half- deconstructed living room. “I keep thinking I have enough, but the moment I look away, my things start multiplying.”
“I think you ought to just stop packing,” he said. “Really though, this is idiotic, your moving out. What are you doing?”
He was about to kiss me, so said his expression. Dreamy-eyed. He was about to kiss me while making a joke of it with his exuberance.
“Things worked out,” I said. “And now Sean Penn is knocking on your door.”
This sounded more resentful than I’d intended, and it surprised us both. I skirted the ugly feeling by launching from the couch to look out the window. I feigned interest in the traffic below. I said that I’d miss our apartment while looking at the main feature that I would not miss. Our apartment perched over the 101, so at all times the sound of speeding cars roared through the rooms. We called it the LA River.
————
Sean Penn never came to dinner. For weeks after I moved out, the dinner seemed like a done deal, and then, all of a sudden, it was out of the question. I knew what a blow that had been for Eduardo. For my part, I’d spent years feeling lost and stagnant in graduate school. After I left, time skittered away from me. Three years passed. Dan and I married in New Jersey on his parents’ property. I found my nonprofit work frustrating and occasionally rewarding. We had season tickets to the Hollywood Bowl. We were in the midst of a yearlong cajoling of my uterus to accept an egg. And then I received a text from Eduardo with a Vimeo link.
He’d since moved back to Montevideo, where he spent three years editing the film to his satisfaction. It was finally done.
I must have been nervous. It took me four days to sit down and watch it, alone, in our apartment. The film opened with Eduardo’s narration, and I was struck by the voice of my friend. It had been so long since I’d heard it. The way the film moved—the connections between shots—there was a humor that felt so much like him. It was like being in the room with him again, witnessing his mind at work.
I’d expected the film to be about Evangeline, but it wasn’t, not quite. The story was told through the men and women who took rides with her as part of the lottery. In this way, a shadowy portrait of Evangeline emerged. The people who entered were mostly men. A contractor from Iowa admitted he hoped to have sex with her, ideally in the car. An art student painted her nude. One young woman ended up as Evangeline’s assistant for two bumpy years. A software engineer had misunderstood and thought he was entering to win the convertible. Eduardo said he’d confused art and romance. He was in our apartment as he spoke to the camera. He sat, in fact, in a velvet armchair I’d found on Edgeware Road and in the glow of a lamp I’d also left behind. Behind him, the rumbling of the interstate. I had the feeling that my old life was still happening—that my old apartment was as I’d left it and my friend still there. I thought the door of my past had cracked open, and I could slip back in if I chose. I, too, might have made a film. We might have made films together. Maybe, even, in Montevideo. “Because I was a filmmaker who’d never made a film before,” Eduardo said. “I’d been searching for a subject. The lottery intrigued me and seemed universal in a way. Who doesn’t want time spent with them to feel like a prize?”
I thought that Eduardo of the past would, at any moment, address me directly with a regret, a prediction, an invitation. It’s not that I wanted to walk away from the life I’d built. I just wanted to be asked. But aside from my old furniture’s cameo, I’d left no impression on the film at all. This offended my sense of nostalgia, but it was a good film. Eduardo had talent. I was glad he’d edited Evangeline out. Her absence loomed over the film, made it funnier, more clever. I did wonder about all that footage. He must have hours of intimate recordings of her. Footage I’m sure she wanted out in the world. This decision hinted at the nature of their split, or maybe it was the very reason things ended. I can’t say I know the details.
The software engineer grinned at the camera and shrugged. “I’ve always wanted to win the lottery,” he said. That was a joke in the film and a revelation to me—everyone who entered the lottery, won.
Joselyn Takacs is the author of the novel Pearce Oysters. Her short fiction has appeared in Gulf Coast, Narrative, Tin House, The Rumpus, Harvard Review, and elsewhere. She holds a PhD in Literature and Creative Writing from the University of Southern California and an MFA from Johns Hopkins University. She lives in Portland, Oregon.