I left the country for the first time when I was twenty-five. My boyfriend, Solomon, invited me on a family trip just as I realized I didn’t love him and never would. It was February and we had been together for six months or so. He was handsome, square jawed and thick haired. I liked the dripping way his name wrapped around my tongue, all o’s, and his quietness. At first I was sure it concealed some immense depth, but it didn’t; it was just social anxiety. He was boring in an inoffensive way—the kind of man who cooked one pasta dish and loved Nolan films. I did like him and enjoyed the comfortable pattern of frequent sex and weekend outings, but this was the relationship that taught me there’s a difference between someone you love and a friend you like to fuck.
I could have ended things right when he invited me, but his parents had offered to pay for everything—flights, the rental home. I didn’t know when I’d get another chance to travel. My job writing “Happy Birthday” on chocolate cakes at Whole Foods didn’t exactly leave me with much spending money. I kept a valid passport because my parents insisted it was good to have, but I’d never used it. I thought of warm air and the kind of jewel-blue sea I’d only seen on TV. I decided I could tolerate how much he and his family would hate me later.
From the moment we emerged through the airport doors, I loved this new place absolutely. It was the dry season, but still damper than anything I’d ever experienced in the Northeast. The warm press of tropical humidity made me feel slow in just the right way. Solomon’s parents were out hiking when we arrived, and tired from the early flight, I slept through most of the afternoon. Around dinner, I showered and decided to show my face. Walking barefoot around the beachside rental, I could tell the price of my flight was nothing to Solomon’s family. The house was large, freshly painted, spotless. Nature barely intruded inside it, despite the large-leafed foliage threatening to burst through every window.
Only Solomon’s mother was in the kitchen when I came down in a sundress, my damp hair leaving spots on its flimsy fabric. She had her back to me, washing some dishes in the sink. She was extraordinarily petite, with honey-colored hair in a neat French braid down her back. I pulled one of the wooden dining chairs from the table to sit, and she turned at the sound.
“Oh.” She shut off the faucet and wiped her hands on a dish towel. “You must be Neha.”
“Hi,” I said, at a loss. The woman bore no resemblance to Solomon, who was tall and well-built with dark hair. She was pale, though the sun she’d gotten in the past few days left a smattering of faint freckles along her shoulders and cheeks. When she smiled, her eyes and mouth folded up elegantly. It was all so perfect, I felt struck.
She seemed to be assessing me with the same gaze. After a long pause, she said, “Aren’t you beautiful.”
I wanted to throw the words back at her, like a slap.
“Hey, look who’s up!” Solomon and his father came bursting through the double doors leading to the patio and pool. Dripping in their towels, they filled the room with masculine energy, a welcome release from how winded I was a moment ago. Solomon’s father pulled me immediately into a wet hug. He was a solid, hairy man, and Solomon looked almost exactly like him. Between them, his mother seemed a different species.
Over dinner, Solomon’s father did most of the talking. He asked me a lot of questions, which I answered as politely as I could. His name was Ben and his wife’s name was Jordana. I realized Solomon’s introversion was the trait that had come from his mother, who quietly deboned her slice of fish with slender fingers as though it was her singular purpose.
That night, Solomon and I lay in the bed together, not touching. “It’s too hot,” he said apologetically. He was shining with sweat.
“It’s fine,” I replied. Solomon felt a strange need to worship me in bed, and it was getting old. All the You’re so beautifuls and I’m so luckys whispered into my skin were at first kind of endearing, but had lately soured to corny and irritating. I had stopped initiating physical intimacy some weeks earlier and was waiting for him to notice. He hadn’t. After spending the evening in the pool with his father, Solomon was quick to fall asleep. Meanwhile I was restless. My nap had been too deep, a miscalculation. I left the bed to wander the house, hoping to tire myself out.
Downstairs the kitchen light was on, but nobody was there. I poured myself a glass of water. The dishes from dinner were still dirty in the sink, fish bones glistening on the oily plates like animal hairs. I walked around the table to gaze out at the alien glow of the pool. Towels and clothes were discarded on the lounge chairs. Through the gaps in the plants at the edges of the patio, I saw movement. I rested my forehead against the warm glass, tilting to press my ear to the door. I heard only faint splashing. I found a large enough opening between fronds to catch a full view of Jordana, body in the pool, elbows resting on the rough concrete edge. At first I was preoccupied by the odd look on her face, as though she were possessed by some spirit. She bobbed strangely in the water, mouth open. Ben’s hand came in and grabbed a fistful of her hair, and I leaned to get a better look.
They were fucking unabashedly in the open air. The indiscretion fascinated me; my own parents would never be so bold. As if sucked in by my curiosity, the distant look in Jordana’s eyes settled, changed slightly. She saw me.
I expected her to stop and bring us into the flurry of awkwardness that should follow such an encounter, but she didn’t. She allowed Ben to continue without breaking the rhythm of her sway or her eye contact with me. We stood in this stalemate for too long, until I realized that I would have to be the one to look away.
————
The next morning, Jordana served us omelets and asked, “How did you sleep?”
“Could’ve been better,” Solomon said. He did indeed look a bit worn out. “I was really hot.”
“You should have said something, hon.” Jordana ran her hand through Solomon’s hair as she passed behind his chair, a loose and familiar movement. I could imagine a time when she did this decades ago, and Solomon’s whole head fit into her small palm. “We’ve gotten used to the weather in the past couple of weeks. We’ll turn up the air conditioning tonight.” She placed a shining fork next to my wrist.
“What about you, Neha?” Ben called from the stove.
“Fell asleep as soon as my head hit the pillow,” I said, looking up at Jordana. Her gray eyes rested on mine for a beat before she turned away. A splotchy redness appeared on her neck, and I covered my smile with a bite of egg.
“Must be so nice to be made for the tropics,” Solomon said, in a way that was supposed to be flirty.
“Sure,” I said dismissively and watched Jordana’s attention shift to her son with a blank, bored look.
That afternoon we hiked to the beach. The path to the shore took us through a small patch of rainforest, well-manicured for tourists. “We didn’t want to scare you off with anywhere too rugged,” Ben told me with a wink as we crossed a wooden bridge over a stream, jade water trickling by below. “Solomon told us you’re not very outdoorsy.”
I glanced back at Solomon, who was keeping pace with Jordana. This information, though harmless, felt like a violation. I was aware that he must have prefaced my introduction with phone calls describing me, maybe for weeks. I hated to imagine how he summarized me. He must have used at least some of the same words he said in bed. The thought gave me a chill.
Both Ben and Jordana were wearing ridiculous floppy bucket hats, and Solomon had on a gray Red Sox cap. The stereotypical American tourist look of it embarrassed me. When Ben pointed out a monkey in the foliage and Solomon hurried across the bridge to take photos, I slipped past, hoping I could somehow avoid association. The monkeys creeped me out. They had weird beady eyes that were too intelligent and surveyed us as we surveyed them, and I wanted to pass by them quickly.
I was a few paces ahead, and Jordana jogged over to catch up.
“Can you swim?” she asked as we walked together, stretching the space between us and our partners.
“Badly,” I replied. “What about you?”
“Not at all,” she said. “I actually hate the ocean. Why would we, as land animals, go in there?”
I was surprised at the bitterness in her voice. I tried to recall how Solomon had described her. Short. Interior designer. Runs marathons. Likes baking. He had told me nothing about her, really. A man could never summarize a woman in any meaningful way. This comforted me; Jordana was in her late forties so anything I was realizing now would have cemented in her years ago. She wouldn’t presume to know me through Solomon’s secondhand the way his father seemed to. Unlike parents of other friends, she didn’t make me feel like a child. We were two women moving through a damp tunnel of trees on unfamiliar terrain.
“I like the ocean,” I said. “It makes me feel small.”
“I don’t need the ocean to feel that.” I couldn’t tell if she was referring to her height or what. It was hard to tell whether her sarcastic tone was meant to have some double meaning or just indicate a general unhappiness. I was certain she was unhappy, but I didn’t know her enough to tell if her sourness was because we were fast approaching the shore she despised or something deeper.
This ocean was entirely new to me. I had been raised on a northern coast, gray and desolate. There was a patch of summer when the Atlantic was bearable, a sickly green tint to its slate, and we all went shivering into the water. Florida’s ocean was more pleasant, but not like this. An ecstatic blue I haven’t seen since. I loved the way the jungle curled into it like a bright young caterpillar.
The sky was completely clear, but the beach was neither full nor empty, with a moderate amount of people dotting the sand. It was perfect. As soon as we had fluttered open our towels and settled our bags on our piece of the shore, I threw off my clothes and dove straight into the water. It was warmer than I expected. I went headfirst into the breaking wave and emerged coughing but joyful. The rush of saltwater into my nose made my eyes sting and my muscles tense. Jordana was wrong in this. As a land animal, I very much needed to be immersed in the sea every now and then to feel real, my body affirming itself in how much water it could displace, how each wave slapped its skin, the way its lungs craved air. I returned to the towels dripping, my feet crusted in sand.
“Having fun?” Solomon smiled up at me from where he sat crisscross on a towel, shielding his eyes with his hand.
I lay on his warm, hairy legs, my delight prompting unusual affection. He leaned down to kiss my wet mouth and I let him. I remembered all the things I liked about him: his big hand heating my cold thigh, how easy it was to spend a day together, the singular way he looked at me. Soon I would have to break his heart, and for the first time, I felt a little bad about it. I sat up and curled into myself, afraid my face would somehow betray my plans of betrayal. Solomon and Ben bounded away to get in a dip, and I was left lying on the towel next to Jordana, who was still wearing her hat and all her clothes, a paperback propped on her knees as she leaned back. Rather than reading, she was watching me.
I stretched my arms above my head and arched my chest to the sun for a sharp yawn before I settled back onto the towel. “What are you thinking about?” I asked her.
“Youth,” she said simply. “How long have you and Solomon been together?”
“I dunno.” I shrugged. “Around half a year?”
“You’re already past counting?” One of her eyebrows twitched slightly, adding a touch of humor to her question.
“We’re not teenagers.” I fished my sunglasses from my bag and put them on.
“What do you like about him?”
“He’s very nice.” I rolled onto my stomach so I could face her. “Am I being interrogated?”
She closed her paperback. “I was curious. Nice, is it?”
“Surprisingly hard to come by these days.”
Her answering gaze sent goosebumps across my skin. I see you, it seemed to say.
“What do you like about Ben?”
She laughed, short, through her nose. “What a question to ask someone almost thirty years married.”
“Come on,” I said. “What keeps someone thirty years married?”
“I don’t know,” she replied, her voice a perfect neutral that gave no indication of the emotion behind it. “After so many years, it doesn’t matter. I don’t know anymore who I was before him, or who I could be without. Our lives are one thing.”
“I think they call that codependency.” “Oh, please,” she said but left it at that.
I thought of a night some weeks earlier, when I told my friend I was considering breaking up with Solomon, though I couldn’t give her a good reason for it. She had told me, half-joking, that in this world, there are lovers and fuckers. Everyone is one or the other. Solomon was a lover, of course. Ben, I didn’t know well enough to say which. But I knew, undoubtedly, Jordana and I were two fuckers clocking each other across a room.
I lay on my stomach and felt the sun warm my back. The wave sounds soothed me. I was surprised that life could be so pleasant. Out in the sea, Ben and Solomon raced each other toward the far-off horizon, leaving a trail white and thin as a scar.
————
On Saturday, we went on a hike after all, though a meager one for my benefit, full of wet trees, deep blue pools, beetles glossy as cat eyes. We ate by the ocean, danced together at a bar after too many drinks. Sunday, Solomon and Ben decided to go on a father-son outing to a volcano some hours away. Jordana and I made a big fuss of bonding until they had left the house, then slid quietly into separate rooms. We had nothing to share but our desire for solitude. I retreated upstairs and opened my book on the balcony. Below me, Jordana unrolled her yoga mat by the pool. I tried to focus on the recently adapted thriller I’d picked up at the airport, but my eyes kept getting caught on the motion of Jordana flowing from pose to pose in her swimsuit. She was clearly an experienced practitioner. Her poses were sculptural and still. It made me want to blow on the miniature of her figure to see if she’d sway. The sun shone brighter and brighter on her skin as sweat accumulated. Soon, she mirrored the rippling surface of the pool, light dancing in hot globs on her shoulders and chest. As she folded her legs and arched her back to touch her toes from behind, she looked right at me. She held the pose and my gaze, breathing slow and heavy, and my cheeks warmed at the intimacy of it. Her mouth, parted, loosened and tightened with each breath, and it made me clench with some embarrassed tension not far from arousal. I put my book between us as she had at the beach and succeeded only in reading a single sentence over and over: Sometimes I think illness sits inside every woman, waiting for the right moment to bloom. And I did feel a little ill, though maybe that was the sun.
“Neha.” Jordana’s voice felt somehow part of the ambiance of bird calls and the slow trickle of the water feature at one end of the pool.
“Would you like to come for a swim?”
“Sure,” I said. My attempt at reading was going nowhere, and I was hot.
I emerged shortly in my most flattering bikini, which I hadn’t worn yet; during one foray into a hot tub that autumn, Solomon had said repeatedly how much he loved the stringy, strappy thing, and had fucked me on the couch while his roommates were out after we got home, fingers stuck all inside the bikini’s copious laces. I don’t know what satisfied me more: that Solomon wouldn’t see it, or how Jordana appraised me lengthily from Sukhasana, palms pressed at her chest like I was a blessing.
“God, I remember when I looked like that,” she said as I sat by the poolside.
“You look great,” I said, with a touch of annoyance. She’d literally never looked like this. She was slimmer than me, much more muscular, her one piece coming down taut over her flat stomach. I hated when perfectly conventional, symmetrical women complimented my body as if they would ever want to be inside it.
“Trust me, it doesn’t look that great underneath all this.” She gestured over her middle.
“It seems to be good enough for Ben.” I said this impulsively, then regretted it and looked away.
“Will you keep alluding to that?” she asked.
“To what?” I quirked an eyebrow.
She laughed and its girlishness surprised me. I didn’t expect her to make such a sweet sound. “Okay, I’m sorry.” She left her yoga mat to sit beside me. “I shouldn’t have let that happen. I just . . . I didn’t want to have the whole interaction of being caught, and I don’t think you did either. How would you face Ben the next day?”
“I faced you.”
She smiled, scrunching her face against the sun. “I can handle it.”
We were sitting pretty close then, my feet dipped into the cool water, hers curled up to her chest. “That was crazy of you guys. What if I was Solomon?”
She lifted her eyebrows like, oh well. “He’s caught us before. It’s not a crazy thing, two adults. Married, consenting.”
I made a face and she laughed again, leaning her cheek on her knees. Her braid fell from her shoulder down her back. Before I could stop myself, I touched it. She looked at my hand. “Want me to do yours?”
I nodded and she knelt behind me, gently laying all my hair behind my shoulders. The light touch of her fingers behind my ears, along my neck, tugging gently at my roots, gave me goosebumps.
“So,” she said as she started working with the hair close to my scalp.
“When are you going to break up with Solomon?”
Despite the topic, I was glad she said something to cover the weird stutters in my breathing. “Do you want me to?” I asked, my own voice faint.
“It doesn’t matter what I want. You obviously want to.”
“Do you think he knows?”
“Maybe. Solomon is pretty good natured, but it makes him hard to read. I don’t think he’d act any different if he did.” She pulled a little tighter as she gathered more strands and built the French braid like vertebrae down my head.
“I’m sorry.” Lame, but I didn’t know what else to say.
She laughed, the breath of it on the nape of my neck. “Don’t be. I actually do want you to break up with him. You’re too interesting for him.”
“Oh,” I said stupidly. I wasn’t sure if that was a compliment or some other thing that had to do with my skin or thick hair. I couldn’t help but feel that Jordana saw me as Solomon did, graceful and beautiful just because I was something they weren’t used to. An icky kind of admiration.
“It’ll be good for him,” she continued. “A little character growth. Everyone goes through it. I haven’t dated anyone but Ben, so I’m almost jealous.”
“You’ve never had a breakup?” I asked, condescending.
“Back in the day, we didn’t shop around so much.”
“Don’t be boring.” It was almost comforting that despite seeming like a creature all her own, Jordana could still be trite.
She yanked a little on my hair and said, in a smooth, teasing voice, “Aren’t you disrespectful.” I swallowed, not wanting to admit I liked it.
She continued quietly braiding for a little while as I watched a bright bird hop around the other side of the pool before flitting away. To fill the silence, I asked, “When did you know you loved Ben?” I realized we had only talked about Ben and Solomon on this trip, and I’d learned nothing about her in the past forty-eight hours. All weekend, she remained an opaque sculpture in the corner, often gazing out at passersby, offering none of her inner life. It seemed like she had no desire to connect with me at all.
“Now who’s being boring,” Jordana chided. “I hate it when young people ask me stupid things like that. Love isn’t this magical state that comes upon you one day. You choose it.”
“That’s bleak.”
“I had my doubts like anyone else.” Jordana ignored my interjection.
“I met Ben at a bar when I was in college. He was a bit older than me, and I was a pretty thing with lots of options.” I imagined it cinematically. Jordana, young and pale, a ponytail maybe. A leather barstool, a neonlaced jukebox. Her sweet mouth. “I almost broke up with him once,” she continued. “I was very close. I think he sensed it too, because out of the blue he got me this gift on one of his business trips to Europe. A beautiful ceramic box, with little gold feet and blue flowers. I think he got it in Switzerland or something, I don’t know. He told me the box was less important than what was inside. That it was all his love in there, every last drop, and he wanted to give it to me.” I snorted, and I felt that she was smiling too, even though I couldn’t turn around. “I know, so stupid. But my friends at the time thought it was romantic, and the whole thing was kind of charming. His hands were all sweaty when he gave it to me. I felt like he really cared, that he was putting it all out there for me. And that was something. Do you have a hair tie?”
I plucked one off my wrist and handed it to her. “What’s the moral of the story?”
I felt her shrug. “It’s just how it happened for me. I accepted his silly gesture, and now we’re very happy.”
“Is that all?” It wasn’t, I already knew.
Jordana silently wound the loose tie around and around, then said, softly, “For a while, whenever I opened the thing, all I could think was, he gave me an empty fucking box.” She let the new braid fall against my back. “Until one day, it wasn’t empty anymore.”
I looked over my shoulder. “So, what? You have to know the box is empty and take it anyway?” I asked, tired of the analogy, if there was one. But her expression was something distant and dark, out of place for such a saccharine anecdote.
“You choose the box,” she said, her voice strange. “And then find out what’s in it.”
Before I could ask anything more, Jordana stood up and plunged straight into the water. I watched the trembling surface until her pale head emerged halfway across the pool. She didn’t turn to look at me, and I realized the story had ended abruptly. I didn’t fully understand what she was trying to tell me. And maybe that was the point. I dove in after her and we didn’t speak again all afternoon. We dozed wet on the warm stones in silence until the sun dipped and we took our separate showers. It was dark when the men returned with dinner. Our matching French braids led them to believe we had bonded after all, and we allowed the misunderstanding. The next morning, Solomon and I flew home, and two weeks later I broke up with him. Solomon wasn’t surprised. I asked if he was mad at me for going on the trip regardless, and he said no. He had a feeling things were cooling on my end but didn’t want to deprive me of a rare vacation. In the end, we had fun, and it was a nice capstone on our relationship, which wasn’t that serious to begin with. The conversation made me regret letting go of him for a moment; I already knew it would be hard to meet another man as easygoing. Still, I couldn’t change how I felt. It was a little embarrassing that after all my agonizing, I inflicted none of the great heartbreak I’d expected to. I had overestimated his feelings for me. After the standard period of awkwardness, we became friends, and some years passed like that.
————
It was autumn and just getting cold when Solomon called to say his father died. It had been eight years since I last saw Ben on that trip. I was shaken by the news, mostly because it was uncommon for someone our age to lose a parent. I still don’t know why Solomon called me when it happened. Our lives were separate at that point. Maybe it was because I was one of the few girlfriends who’d met his parents, however briefly, and by some grief-logic that compelled him to pick up the phone.
Solomon and I were no longer people our friends could imagine together. He had gotten more outdoorsy, while I’d cut my hair short and moved into admin work. He was engaged, and I dated around without any conviction as all my friends paired up, until I accidentally stumbled into a polycule when I met someone at a concert who already had two other girlfriends. I found all three of them a bit dorky and annoying but kept it up because I was lonely and the sex was decent. Solomon and I got together only occasionally out of nostalgia. His fiancée liked me, but I found them a bit hard to hang out with, too. They were mundanely happy and a little too riveted by my “wild stories” in a way that made me feel clownish. Even if we acted like I was in on the joke, it was humiliating.
I think it was some Jewish custom to bury the body immediately, because the funeral was the next day, in the middle of the week. I
wasn’t inner circle enough to attend the burial itself, but I went to the memorial afterward. I was a receptionist at a ridiculously nice private school; I had to drag myself out of bed at five in the morning to arrive on time and spent weekdays barely conscious, limply telling middle schoolers in designer shoes not to run in the hallways and helping wives of execs and athletes fill out forms. I wasn’t suited for early mornings and arrived at Solomon’s childhood home yawning even though it was barely six in the evening.
I saw Solomon’s fiancée, Mina, before seeing Solomon himself. After a few flings, Solomon’s next long-term relationship was with another Indian girl. If either of us had any thoughts on this coincidence, we left them unsaid because things were otherwise just fine. Mina was unlike me in every way—a nurse with B-cups who loved hiking, smart and non-judgmental, and basically unhateable despite my best efforts. A lover, through and through. She met me at the door in a neat, kneelength black dress, her long hair tucked behind tiny ears dotted with gold studs. She grasped my hands, all perfume and mint. “Thank you so much for coming,” she said breathily, making urgent eye contact. I could tell this was her daughter-in-law dry run and squeezed back with my best sympathetic smile. “Of course.”
Solomon was caught in a long conversation with some older men who were shorter than him, looking like a morose camp counselor. I went immediately for the coffee and cookies table and lingered there among the children, hoping I could somehow jump-start my brain before I had to talk to him. I tried to remember what I could about Ben, but we had only met on the one trip and my takeaway was limited: he was big and loud. I rifled through that weekend for something affectionate and settled on Ben pulling a coy Jordana to dance, face red. How he handed her to Solomon and took me by the waist, twirling us a few times until we were dizzy and laughing. Yes, he had been kind and joyful. I tried to linger in this memory, but by the time Solomon had a moment to greet me, I was holding half a chocolate-chip cookie and remembering Ben railing Jordana in the pool. We hugged, an awkward one-armed motion as I tried to keep the crumbs from his jacket.
“How are you doing,” I asked pointlessly.
“I don’t know,” he replied. “It’s so sudden, there’s so much to do.
It’s going to take a bit to sink in.”
He did look a little dissociated, eyes not quite resting on anything for too long. Maybe that was for the best. There were some relatives around, but Solomon seemed to be doing the heavy lifting. I didn’t know how I’d cope if I were in his place. He looked very tall and young, and my eyes darted appreciatively to little Mina collecting stray plates and napkins. She was good in these situations.
“Where’s your mother?” I asked. “I haven’t seen her.”
Solomon sighed. “Upstairs, probably. My aunt’s been checking on her every now and then. I don’t think she’ll make it down tonight.”
It was hard to imagine Jordana overcome by emotion, but the way she described her marriage was like she and Ben were two limbs on the same body. It had disturbed me at the time, but in my thirties, I wanted it badly. “She really loved him,” I said, not sure if it was the right thing.
Solomon nodded, attention already wandering to the door where a middle-aged couple was entering. “Don’t feel pressured to hang out for too long,” he told me, patting my arm. “I appreciate you coming by.”
We exchanged the usual anything you need and I’m here for you, etc., but I got the sense he would have zero recollection of our conversation in an hour or two. I wasn’t sure when it was right to leave. I nibbled on more snacks, helped Mina with tidying, then finally found some common friends to chat with. Half an hour later, I was ready to go but overflowing with coffee. Both first-floor bathrooms were occupied, so I slipped upstairs while nobody was paying attention. The house was large and Georgian, not unlike the one from Home Alone. I thought I’d have trouble finding what I was looking for, but there was a bathroom right at the landing. I was already sitting when I realized it had two doors, one undoubtedly opening to a bedroom. I tried to finish as quickly as possible. At the sink I noticed the wallpaper had little sailboats. The bedroom on the other side must have been Solomon’s. As I was drying my hands, I saw the door was cracked open. I should have left it, but I’m nosy. I wanted to know how Solomon had grown up, what kind of space cultivated such a solid, average man. I pushed the door lightly to reveal football trophies and karate belts perched on shelves, the wall a midnight blue. A broad desk with a monitor, a child’s acoustic guitar in one corner. It was like a stock photo. By the time I noticed the stockinged feet on the bedspread it was too late, the door was too open.
I was caught by how eight years looked on Jordana. Her honey hair washed out and showing graying roots. The lines on her face deeper, of course. Her paleness had turned somewhat translucent, like onion skin. This was clearly Solomon’s room, but there she was, black dress crumpled around her, his sheets wrinkled and slept on. She looked like a mythical creature felled in a meadow. A tissue box sat untouched on the nightstand while her face shone wet with tears and snot, eyes brutally red.
Almost immediately she said my name shakily, like no time had passed.
“You remember,” I said, opening the door fully.
She tilted her head up. “Yes,” was all she managed before rasping again. I had caught her in some pitiful sobbing session that was meant to go unwitnessed. I should have excused myself right away, but instead I knelt at the foot of the bed and placed a hand on her knee and said, “Look at you.” This only made her cry harder. She grasped my sleeve and I could have hugged her, provided her with any normal gesture of comfort, but I was already not supposed to be there, a warped memory plucked from a warm day years ago. Sometimes when something so unlikely happens, you cease to exist. You enter some other place, a pocket of unreality. I was not there, and neither was she. I took her face in both of my hands and placed my mouth neatly over her right eye-socket and sucked up the salty wetness there, ran my tongue along every new wrinkle. I pressed my lips around her eyelashes and tugged them taut, like a fine paintbrush. I pulled away to her startled face, her wide gray eyes. She had stopped panting and sat with her lips parted and still. She was not breathing at all, not living. She put her hands on my wrists but didn’t push me away. Rather, she dipped her head down so I could do the same to her other eye. When I released her, she crumpled back onto the bed, gasping a little but no longer crying.
“That’s better,” I said and left through the bathroom like nothing had happened.
————
Jordana texted me on Saturday night, while I was at a bar with some friends. I expected the notification to be from the person I was dating but instead read Jordana (Solomon’s Mom) on my screen. I must have saved her in my contacts that one weekend, and the cloud silently carried her name and number from phone to phone in the intervening years. In the same way, it kept mine with her. I slid my phone under the table to open the message.
Are you awake, it asked.
I laughed through my nose at receiving a “You up” text from Solomon’s grieving mother.
“Who is it?” my friend asked, leaning in curiously, and I turned the screen against my stomach.
“No one. An old friend,” I said. I waited for her attention to return to the conversation before replying to Jordana: Of course. It’s not that late.
She replied almost immediately, like she had been waiting there staring at our messages, the last of which had been a series of whereabouts we had sent each other during the trip. Would you like to have coffee? I can go to you.
It was past ten and nearly every coffee shop was closed. We met at a 24-hour donut shop near the bar I had left suddenly, to everyone’s suspicion. Jordana arrived to find me eating a powdered donut, lips caked white. I licked them as she sat down and without asking, took a sip of my lukewarm coffee. She had thrown a trench coat over athleisure and looked haunted, like she was about to pull me into some crime noir.
“This is sudden.”
“I couldn’t sleep,” she said, as if that explained everything.
“Why didn’t you call Mina?”
She laughed, coughing as she tried to swallow another gulp of coffee.
“You don’t like her?”
Her fit subsided and she said, “I love her.”
“Then what are we doing here?”
Jordana leaned forward, her elbows on the table. She bowed her head to me, her scalp a white snake through her hair. “I don’t know. I can’t sleep.”
“Is that why you were in Solomon’s bed?”
“Our bedroom is just.” She shivered and took a bite of my donut, her lips sugaring comically.
I didn’t know what to do. She was clearly having a meltdown of sorts. I reminded myself that it was my fault that we were in this situation. I could have shut the door.
I touched her hand. “Do you want your own donut?”
She shook her head. After a silence, she asked, “Do you remember the box?”
It took me a moment to figure out what she was talking about. I had forgotten until I heard the word in her voice. The box that was empty until it wasn’t. “Sure,” I said.
“I thought . . . ” Her breath rattled. “I thought after Ben died it would be empty again. But it’s not.”
I had a feeling she might start crying so I squeezed her fingers.
“It won’t let me sleep,” she continued. “Like all of this is my fault.”
“Of course not.” I didn’t know the circumstances of Ben’s death, except that it had been an unexpected stroke. I didn’t know if he was at home or out, whether it happened at night or in broad daylight. Had Jordana been with him when it happened? I was afraid to ask, in case it made her spiral further.
She looked up at me, red eyes watering, giving her the murine look of a temperamental chihuahua. “You know, you’re the only person I’ve ever told about the box.”
I looked at her doubtfully. “I’m pretty sure you told me your friends liked it.”
“No, I mean . . . ” She exhaled. “That it wasn’t empty.”
At that point I lost the thread on the box metaphor, if I ever grasped it to begin with. My memory of the conversation was a little fuzzy. I wasn’t sure if I remembered her actual words or a summary my brain had transplanted into her mouth. I thought the box’s non-emptiness was Jordana’s way of saying she loved Ben after all. But this was known well, murmured about ad nauseam by everyone at the memorial. I gleaned that they lived an enviable life, full of affection and affluence, and maybe there were even people who privately felt comforted by her current suffering. Anything can happen, I overheard someone say, unable to hide that satisfaction in her voice. I wondered if I would feel similarly about Solomon and Mina years later. If I felt it even then,
watching Jordana tremble over this laminate table.
“Why me?”
“I didn’t think I’d see you again,” she said. “And I needed to tell someone eventually. Why not you.”
I reached across the table and took her chin in my hand. “Is that the only reason?”
She had trouble holding my gaze. I recognized that I had some power over her, though I didn’t understand it myself. Maybe it was my relative youth, my randomness. I don’t think we recognized each other as real people. Neither of us could breathe a word of this encounter to anyone, it was so weird and inappropriate. It emboldened me to stand up and lick the powder from her mouth, just to see what would happen.
When I pulled back, she looked less surprised than I thought she would. Like she had expected this exact thing. I sat down. “Do you want a ride home?” she asked, like nothing had happened.
“Sure,” I said and followed her outside. I had no intention of going home; I had been pregaming a birthday party before Jordana messaged and was planning to meet my friends there after I was done with whatever this would be. I knew, despite her offer, it wasn’t over yet.
In her SUV she asked me for an address, and I said, “What about the box?”
She paused with her fingers on the navigation screen. “That’s my problem.”
“You’ve made it my problem, too.” I reached in and tapped Go Home. The navigation told her to head straight in a soothing voice. I settled back in the leather seat. “Can you turn on the heat?” The evening had cooled. The leather jacket I wore wasn’t enough now that the alcohol was ebbing. Jordana didn’t protest, only eased out of her parking space. The car warmed slowly as we moved beyond the denser parts of the city into a more residential area, the houses turning prettier, the landscaping neater.
All the windows of Jordana’s house were dark when we arrived. Inside, she began taking her shoes off without touching a switch. I wondered if she had climbed out of bed and left like this, in complete darkness. I followed her lead, sliding off my boots on the hallway rug. The house looked bigger with no one in it. Plastic containers of untouched snacks and desserts gleamed on the countertop. Bottles of wine, the carafe I’d pulled coffee from, some trays covered in foil created a small city on the kitchen island. It made me feel like any minute now, a party would emerge from the corners, yelling Surprise!
Jordana placed her hands on the island like she was debating whether she should offer me something. I held her shoulders and pressed my cold nose onto the back of her neck. “What now?” I whispered into her spine.
She turned her head and said to me in profile, “I think you know.” I bit her cheek. She turned and put her hands on my ribcage with an even pressure that made it unclear whether she was pulling me toward her or pushing me away. I bit her lip. I didn’t want to kiss her until she kissed me. This felt important; it gave me the upper hand. It would have to be her transgression first, and that itself would be a submission. When she didn’t close the space, I took her hand and led her upstairs. Jordana trailed somberly. I could tell she would have rather stayed in the kitchen, but that wasn’t why I came.
Their bedroom was large and beautiful, arranged with wooden furniture, an antique vanity. A wide, plush rug covered a large portion of the room. It felt wooly and luxurious under my bare feet. The two wide windows faced the street, setting the room aglow with a silvery light that came from the streetlamp outside, but still felt like moonlight. I threw myself on the bed. An egregiously comfortable mattress.
Jordana hesitated, stood at the edge of the bed, silhouetted against the windows. “Come here,” I said and held out my hand. For a moment she just looked at it, unmoving. I couldn’t make out her face. It was a little scary, what I imagined people with sleep paralysis saw when they tried to open their eyes. But then she placed her dry palm in mine, and I pulled her to me. She curled against me like a child. She was so thin, her bones prodded me all over. Her body had changed too, lost a lot of its muscle. If I saw her again in eight years, would she have even less substance?
“Don’t you hear it?” she asked.
“I only hear you,” I said. This was true. She was breathing loudly. I pulled her thigh over me and after some resistance, she sat astride me. I sat up and ran my face along her sternum and my hands into her hair. She smelled a little unshowered, expensive perfume layered over the body musk. I pressed my face into her neck. “Enough,” I said.
I yanked at her hair and finally, she kissed me fully, tongue and everything. It was so interesting. I don’t know if I was aroused, not the way I might have been in different circumstances. I couldn’t stop reflecting on the moment as it unfolded, like it had already happened. But she seemed to be into it. It did something for her, and that did something for me. We took off our clothes. She wasn’t wearing a bra under her top, and her breasts fell out limp and anticlimactic, unlike my own, which were already halfway bursting out of my ill-fitting bra before I unhooked it. She touched them earnestly as soon as they were bare. The possibility that she thought I was hotter than her was hot to me. My entire life I found it difficult to measure my relative attractiveness to exactly the type of woman she once was—skinny and pert. White, of course. I would rarely admit it, but an adolescence of being completely unseen as a sexual object by my peers had convinced my subconscious that I was grotesque in comparison. And here she was, trying unsubtly to move closer so I wouldn’t look too long at her body, which had its own network of folds entirely different from the way my flesh folded. The beauty we saw in each other was in direct relief to the ugliness we perceived in ourselves. It satisfied my self-hatred so completely, it actually made me horny. I found her exquisite, her gray eyes, how opal she was in that false moonlight. Her nipples pink as jam stains. She pulled my hand between her legs and I stuck my fingers straight inside her. She jerked in response. For all her enthusiasm, she was pretty dry; I’d gotten ahead of myself, and maybe it wasn’t that pleasant. I had my mouth on her to fix this when I realized she was crying. I tried to lift my face and stop—I had never actually been so good or bad that someone began to cry, and I wasn’t sure what to do—but she took me by the hair and pressed me back down. The crying had nothing to do with me. She was going through something privately, and even with my tongue actually inside her, I was outside of it. She was a stone woman, sleek and veined. I would leave the house having learned nothing substantial about her. At least, with some effort between sobs, she came.
————
I’m not a monster; I didn’t expect reciprocation. Once her breathing eased, I handed over her robe. She lay there for a little while and then got in the shower. I was dressed by the time she emerged, flushed and jasmine scented. I held her until she fell asleep. I thought there would be more to this encounter than one weak, weepy orgasm, but she was out fast. I still had time to make it to this party, be long gone by the time Jordana woke up. We wouldn’t see each other again until Solomon’s wedding, where
we would act like we hadn’t seen each other since Costa Rica.
Just as I was leaving, I heard something strange. At first I thought it was scratching but then realized it was a warbling mumble. Almost like someone had left the television on in a different part of the house. I stood at the center of the room, trying to triangulate it. The vanity.
I opened every drawer until finally the sound came a little louder out of one. It was stuffed full of silken scarves, and digging inside, my hand closed around a ceramic box. I glanced at Jordana to find her still asleep. I took the box, cocooned in a handful of scarves, into the en suite and closed the door. The bathroom was still muggy from her shower. I put on the exhaust, both to suck away the humidity and create some white noise over whatever this was. Jordana hadn’t been lying; the box really was making sounds. I wondered if it was a music box that had gone weird with time. How old was it now, fifty years? I unsheathed it to find that it was antique, so much older. The mumble became clearer, really like a person’s voice, though the syllables were all jumbled. I opened the lid.
I will try my best to describe what was inside, though it’s almost too strange for words and has the elusive quality of a dream. It was something like a man, but also a creature, but definitely one with a masculine aura. It smelled kind of bad, like rotting rice. It was hard to tell if it looked like Ben or Jordana or Solomon, but there was something of each in it. It turned its round dark eyes, which seemed to have no whites, no irises, up at me and began muttering at a more frenzied clip. I couldn’t make out what it was saying, it was speaking so fast and hushed. I only caught the rush of sibilants and the pah pah bah bah of plosives amplified like it was speaking against a mic, or right in my ear. I wondered if Jordana understood the thing. It came to the edge and put its little paws on the rim, leaning up to me. The box slid out of my hand and hit the vanity on its side. One gold leg cracked off. The little beast let out a screechy roar as it tumbled into the marble basin. It tried pathetically to climb up but it was somewhat slimy and couldn’t quite get purchase on the smooth slope. I couldn’t begin to fathom what it was. Over the years, I’ve tried to put it together to no avail. Was it a curse, a djinn? One day I remembered Jordana had told me it was maybe from Switzerland and spent a weekend searching Celtic and Germanic folktales but found nothing that matched its description. In time, I came to accept that some monsters went undocumented because people were too ashamed to admit to them. I never told anyone about it, either.
When the creature realized there was no getting up the sink, it whipped its head to me and stopped mumbling, which was almost more unsettling. It smiled, baring teeth. “You,” it said, in clear English, and I quickly clamped my hand around its entire face, though I was loathe to touch it. That was the last straw for me. Whatever it was about to say, I did not want to hear. The image itself was enough, so indescribably horrible. It was surprisingly squishy in my fingers, like one of those toy guys you could splat onto windows and walls. I squeezed harder and its eyes bulged out from the crook of my thumb. That’s when the crunching began. Unable to open its mouth, it let out a shrill, guttural squeal. I gasped and squeezed harder until the whole thing popped and crushed at the same time, like some weird fruit, and my hand filled with gritty ooze. “Shit,” I whispered. I ran the tap and started scrubbing it off, shoving it down the drain as best as I could, though some bits were sticking to the sink. When I stepped back into the bedroom, Jordana was sitting upright in bed, robe clutched around her, breathing hard. She knew what I had done, felt it somewhere deep inside her. She was connected to that thing, whatever it was. She needed it. Why else would she have kept it all this time. Her mouth parted, but she had no words. Her aged body coalesced with my aging one, a murky stew like the one I had just scraped from my palm. One day I might also find myself tethered to something ugly and unspeakable—no, I would, absolutely. We were alike in some way that was abstract but true. I didn’t want to look at her anymore. I fled the house, barely stuffing my feet into my boots before stumbling down the porch steps. I ran half a block before I stopped, panting, to call a ride. Twenty minutes later I was walking into a party where nobody asked where I had been. Someone called out my name, handed me a shot, and we raised our plastic glasses to the birthday girl, thirty-three, in a fluffy pink cowboy hat with lips glossed and eyelids glittering, wrapping me in a sweat-and-tequila hug, crying, “You’re here, you’re here!”